Re-Storying the Archive: Embodied Standpoint Literacy (EmSL) and the Transnational Reimagining of Narrative Pedagogy
by Temitope Ojedele-Adejumo | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Embodied Standpoint Literacy as a Transnational Narrative Framework
Narrative scholarship in Writing Studies and TPC has increasingly emphasized storying as a way of making meaning, shaping ethical awareness, and connecting prior experience to professional practice (Schmertz, 2018; Canagarajah, 2020; Sullivan, 2020; Yang, 2022). Within this scholarship, narrative is understood not simply as a representational account of experience but as an epistemological practice through which writers construct knowledge, negotiate identities, and make sense of their relationships to broader social and institutional contexts (Bleich, 2003; hooks, 2014). This body of work has been particularly important in challenging autonomous models of literacy by demonstrating that literacy is socially situated and enacted through lived experience rather than acquired as a neutral set of technical skills (Street, 1984; Barton & Hamilton, 2012). Consequently, narratives are understood not merely as reflections of literacy but as rhetorical acts that reveal how writers navigate relationships among language, identity, institutions, and power (Alexander, 2015; Canagarajah, 2020).
Despite these important contributions, narrative scholarship also reveals a conceptual tension. Although scholars have demonstrated that literacy narratives are socially situated and shaped by relations of power, much of the literature continues to privilege narrative as a retrospective account of experience. Consequently, analytical attention often centers on interpreting what writers say about their literacy histories rather than examining how those histories become embodied resources for rhetorical action. In other words, narrative is frequently treated as the object of analysis instead of as evidence of the ongoing negotiations through which writers respond to institutional expectations, disciplinary conventions, and broader sociopolitical conditions.
This tendency becomes particularly significant in studies of transnational and diasporic writers. While scholarship has increasingly recognized multilingualism, mobility, and cultural difference as important dimensions of literacy (Canagarajah, 2020; Schmertz, 2018; Yang, 2022), these experiences are often discussed through broad categories of diversity or inclusion. Such approaches risk overlooking how specific geopolitical histories, colonial legacies, migration trajectories, and institutional positioning shape not only the stories writers tell but also the rhetorical decisions they make while composing those stories. As a result, narrative can become detached from the embodied and institutional conditions that both constrain and enable rhetorical action.
One genre that exemplifies both the possibilities and limitations of narrative scholarship is the Literacy Autobiography (LA), also referred to as the literacy narrative (Yang, 2022). As a longstanding pedagogical practice in Writing Studies, LA invites writers to examine how literacy develops through family, schooling, language, migration, and other sociocultural experiences (Brandt, 2001; Soliday, 1994). Influenced by ideological models of literacy, LA reframes literacy not as an autonomous skill but as a socially situated practice shaped by institutional, cultural, and historical contexts (Barton & Hamilton, 2012; Street, 1984). In doing so, it has been instrumental in legitimizing lived experience as a source of literacy knowledge and critical reflection (Canagarajah, 2020; Schmertz, 2018). At the same time, its emphasis on narrating literacy experiences foregrounds representation, raising questions about whether narrative alone sufficiently accounts for the embodied and rhetorical negotiations through which writers respond to institutional expectations.
Although LA legitimizes lived experience as a source of literacy knowledge, scholars caution that the genre can inadvertently reproduce the institutional norms it seeks to challenge. Soliday (1994) argues that literacy narratives often become institutional “passages between language worlds” (p. 511), encouraging writers to produce recognizable stories of literacy development. Similarly, Yancey (2009) notes that literacy narratives are often evaluated according to institutional expectations of growth and success. For multilingual and transnational writers, these expectations may reinforce deficit perspectives by interpreting linguistic and cultural difference as remediation rather than as rhetorical resource (Canagarajah, 2012). This gap, therefore, points to the need for a framework that moves beyond narrative as representation to examine writing as an embodied and situated rhetorical practice. Building on Canagarajah’s (2020) characterization of LA as a “liminal genre” that can be adapted to more expansive contexts (p. 4), I propose EmSL as a framework that shifts attention from what writers narrate about their literacy experiences to how their embodied, transnational, and institutional positionalities shape rhetorical decision-making across writing contexts.
Drawing on Dorothy Smith’s institutional ethnography, EmSL understands everyday experiences as organized through institutional relations that are often mediated by texts (Smith, 2001, 2002, 2005, 2006; LaFrance, 2019). These “boss texts,” such as syllabi, rubrics, assignment prompts, reviewers’ feedback, and other institutional documents, function as coordinating mechanisms that regulate how individuals act and interpret expectations. They do not merely communicate guidelines; they shape the conditions under which meaning is produced and how participants’ agency is negotiated within institutional contexts. At the same time, EmSL draws on feminist standpoint theory (Harding, 2004), to foreground how knowledge is situated and shaped by social position. From this perspective, the experiences of those navigating marginalized and transnational positions are not peripheral but provide critical insight into how institutional structures operate. Extending these frameworks, EmSL further incorporates a chronotopic understanding of literate activity, recognizing that individuals’ engagements with texts and narratives are shaped by layered temporal, spatial, and cultural experiences (Prior & Shipka, 2003). These laminations inform how writers as narrators interpret, respond to, and reposition themselves within institutional contexts.
Taken together, EmSL conceptualizes literacy as an embodied and situated practice through which individuals draw on lived experience, positionality, and institutional knowledge to navigate, negotiate, and reconfigure the conditions that shape meaning-making. When brought into conversation with narrative, EmSL reframes storying as more than a reflective or pedagogical act. It positions narrative as a site of negotiation, where individuals engage the constraints and possibilities of institutional life through the stories they hear, tell, and live. Through this lens, the narratives of AAGS can be understood as situated responses to institutional conditions, revealing how storytelling becomes a means of navigating visibility, authority, and belonging within academic and professional spaces, while also functioning as a transnational case through which broader patterns across diasporic and international communities can be understood.
