Tracing Trajectories
by Andrew Bowman and Bruce Kovanen | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Introduction
“While the state of graduate labor in our field may be dire, we see addressing these concerns as commensurate with and a central part of our scholarship and professional identities” (Bowman & Kovanen, 2020, p. 3).
When returning to our first publication, we were struck by our clarity of vision and what we saw as the work of the field. Our call, both then and now, is tied deeply to our story of becoming organizers and academics. In that initial Xchanges publication, included as part of the Symposium on the Status of Graduate Study in Rhetoric and Composition, we focused our organizing call on fellow graduate workers. We saw this group as among the most precarious within the academy, and we saw how our own work with a graduate worker union, the Graduate Employees’ Organization (GEO) Local 6300, had led to material improvements to our working conditions on campus. We wanted to encourage other workers to engage in similar struggles, as we had seen fellow graduate students in the field do in response to a series of racist and sexist posts on the WPA-L through the creation of the NextGen listserv (Baniya et al., 2021; Kumari et al., 2020) and the related #WPAListservFeministRevolution on the social media platform then known as Twitter (Olejnik & Messina, 2020). Prior to the composition of that article, we had both presented a few times at Conference on College Composition and Communication (CCCC) but had not experienced writing for academic publication. As we moved towards PhD candidacy, we saw the Xchanges call as an opportunity to both gain experience in publication and synthesize our emergent expertise from our reading of exam lists and experiences as organizers in the union. This convergence prompted sustained inquiry into the relationship between academic theory and material practice: how might the conceptual frameworks encountered in our scholarly reading inform, and be informed by, the situated realities of labor organizing?
As we’ve moved into our careers, the level of precarity across the academy has only grown, and organizing academic workers broadly remains a central theme for us because the rate of de-professionalization has only increased. These changes have ushered in what Adrianna Kezar, Tom DePaola, and Daniel Scott (2019) call the “gig academy,” a university transformed into a “patchwork of loosely connected contingent workforces to service both its central missions and its day-to-day operations” (p. 36). Spurred on by transformations in artificial intelligence, increasingly hostile federal education policies, and burgeoning corporate models of academic administration that diminish instructional autonomy (Eaton, 2022; Heller, 2016; Rhoades, 2025), academic workers across rank and classification are increasingly precarious. These events only further accelerate the negative shifts observed by Kezar et. al. (2019). While our academic future may look bleak, appeals to the halcyon days of yore–like referencing decades-past percentages of tenure-line faculty–point to an uncomplicated picture of the academy that is almost entirely fictive (Graff, 2024), rife with its own problems of white racial hegemony (Wilder, 2013). Instead, we must chart a new path, because, if academics do not begin organizing soon, academia as we know it will simply cease to exist.
Now working as a tenure-track professor (Bruce) and a full-time labor organizer (Andy), our reflections will trace our professional trajectories across academia and organizing, arguing for their importance to maintain higher education as a public good. Our 2020 paper in Xchanges was our first peer-reviewed publication, and we used that entrance into academic conversation to highlight the continued importance of organizing, both as a historical antecedent in Rhetoric, Composition, and Writing Studies (Robertson et al., 1987; Sledd, 1991; Wyche, 2017) and based on our own experience as budding labor organizers having recently won a strong collective bargaining agreement after a grueling twelve-day strike (Johnson, 2018) with our union, the GEO. We ended that publication by calling for a renewed focus on the connection between our academic work and our working conditions. This piece and the life histories detailed within provide one framework for noticing the entanglement of these two interests and how they might inform labor organizing efforts across campuses. We see the current struggles of the American academy not as insurmountable obstacles or as an individual mission to solve, but as collective problems that require collective solutions. Organizing and working together within and across our universities can lead us to solutions we would not have discovered or accomplished alone.
In this paper, we trace our diverging but complimentary paths through the academy, demonstrating how academic research can and should live beyond the page (like on the picket line)! Since our Xchanges publication in 2020, we have continued to work together as elected leaders in our union and together in our field as researchers and writers (Bowman et al., 2022; Bowman & Kovanen, 2020; Diab et al., 2025; Kovanen & Bowman, 2021, 2024). While we continue to work together, we have each chosen to focus on different aspects of our overarching academic project. For Bruce, this aspect is research, teaching, and service. Joining the tenure-track faculty of North Dakota State University in the fall of 2024, Bruce dove head-first into scholarship, serving as an editor for two academic journals (Academic Labor: Research and Artistry and Literate Activity: Perspectives on Textual Practices in the World), taking on graduate student advisees, directing the upper division writing program, and serving as the chair of the CCCC Labor Caucus. While his co-author often accuses him of overworking himself, the academy would not exist without the labor of Bruce and many scholars like him. While Andy decided to leave the traditional academic career behind, he did not stray far from campus. Andy currently works as the Lead Staff Organizer for the Campus Faculty Association (CFA), an organizing committee working to unionize the tenure-track faculty at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign (UIUC). UIUC professors are the last faculty at a public university in Illinois to unionize, and their campaign points to the broader turn towards organizing tenure-line faculty at R1 US universities (e.g., Michigan State University’s Union of Tenure System Faculty and the Penn State Faculty Alliance), who now join other long-established and growing unions of graduate workers, non-tenure-line faculty, post-docs, building and food service workers, librarians, and administrative staff (Herbert et al., 2020). While Bruce’s work may be more legible to our readers than Andy’s, we write this piece in part to argue for a more expansive understanding of what “academic work” means, and to argue for a greater focus on what heretofore has often been labeled as “extracurricular” interests. If academics do not attend to their working conditions soon their work and workplaces will be unrecognizable.
