Tracing Trajectories
by Andrew Bowman and Bruce Kovanen | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Research, Teaching, and Service Reexamined
While there are many ways of dividing up academic work, we end this piece by offering some practical advice using the classic tripartite division of research, teaching, and service.
First, rather than positioning scholarship as analytically detached from the conditions of its production, our work suggests political and ethical investment in the problems and solutions research identifies deepens its value. Importantly, this orientation also pushes against the individualizing tendencies of academic research. Collaborative writing, co-authorship, and collective theorizing are not just methodological choices but epistemological commitments that improve the quality of the academic inquiry. Writing together makes us better scholars!
Second, teaching is why we’re here. While research is often held up as the primary work of a tenured professor at many academic institutions, we argue for the valorization of teaching (and service) as co-equal constituents of a well-lived academic life. Teaching, like organizing, is inherently collaborative, giving us the space to build the communities and coalitions that will help us imagine collaborative paths forward for universities and their workers. From this perspective, teaching becomes less about cultivating isolated expertise and more about fostering an awareness of interdependence, how one’s work is shaped by, and contributes to, broader systems of power.
Third, service doesn’t have to come last, and when it’s centered, your view of your workplace and your co-workers can massively improve. We argue that faculty must challenge the marginalization of labor-related work within institutional structures. Service can be reframed as a domain where faculty apply their expertise to shape institution conditions, rather than an inert category for work that doesn’t fit elsewhere.
Underlying all these points is a more fundamental claim: that working conditions are inseparable from learning conditions. The quality of education that institutions provide is directly tied to the stability, support, and autonomy afforded to those who teach and research within them. Faculty therefore have both a professional and ethical stake in advocating for equitable labor conditions across rank and classification.
Finally, we return to the premise at the center of all our work: collective problems demand collective solutions. While the scale of the challenges facing higher education can feel overwhelming, our experiences suggest that change often begins with small, coordinated actions. In light of the recent de-chartering of the Conference on College Composition and Communication (CCCC) by the National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE), we have seen many in our field step up to begin to organize a new path forward, creating regional networks for ideation and new online communities across social media and email listservs. (This is the exact kind of spadework we see as necessary for academic labor!) These actions, when sustained and connected, have the potential to reshape our academic institutions in meaningful ways. To adopt these orientations is not to abandon the core commitments of academic life but to extend them. It is to recognize that knowledge production does not occur in isolation from the conditions under which it is produced, and that faculty have a role to play in shaping those conditions. If the academy is to remain a site of critical inquiry and public good, it will require not only research and teaching, but organizing–the ongoing work of building, sustaining, and transforming the institutions we inhabit.
