Tracing Trajectories
by Andrew Bowman and Bruce Kovanen | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Becoming Academic Organizers
The way to change the field is to organize. We see organizing as a concerted activity in service of material change, a way for people to come together to solve problems–broadly defined–collectively. We have both drawn on the notion of “spadework,” a term coined in the 1960s by key civil rights figure Ella Baker to describe the organizing efforts of the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) (Ransby, 2003). Spadework, described as “the complex, often unseen, and politically fraught work of cultivating everyday grassroots empowerment and resistance,” (Inwood & Alderman, 2022, p. 3723) offers a useful framework for understanding the overlooked or so-called “mundane” aspects of organizing–building relationships and networks of power–rather than only focus on glossy highlights of “action” like protests, strikes, and picket lines.
While spadework is not a term often heard in the academy, service is. Too often, we valorize the specific measurable outputs of academic work: publications, presentations, grants, and so on. Aligning with those who have made similar arguments about the value given to certain kinds of work over others in the academy (Kahn, 2020; Lynch-Biniek & Cox, 2024; Novotny, 2025) we too advocate for more expansive definitions of what can and should count. Often on academic picket lines we hear the call, “Our working conditions are our students’ learning conditions.” Carrying this call into our scholarship and teaching, we return to our initial Xchanges publication to deepen our call to academic laborers of all stripes to organize their campuses and disciplines in defense of academic life, in which we emphasize instructional autonomy, research independence, and student-centered campuses. We share our stories of becoming to help illustrate the entanglement of academic work and labor activism and to show how treating these aspects as separate spheres–similar to the denigration of teaching and service work over research–weakens both our universities and our scholarship.
Bruce
My trajectory from a PhD in writing studies to a tenure-line faculty position reflects an uneven and recursive process across labor advocacy and academic scholarship. After going on strike in 2018, I moved from bargaining team member and grievance chair to co-president of the union. As co-president, I was immediately struck by: 1) The overwhelming variety of texts drafted, circulated, and read by union members and 2) The fact that many previous co-presidents had elected not to finish their doctoral degrees and instead work in labor organizing. As my participation in the labor movement deepened (soon after becoming a Vice President of the Illinois Federation of Teachers [IFT] and serving on the American Federation of Teachers [AFT] Higher Education Program and Policy Council), I began to think about how my dissertation, grounded in the study of literate activity, could be used to examine the literate practices of rank-and-file union members. Defined “as cultural forms of life saturated with textuality, that is strongly motivated and mediated by texts,” (Prior, 1998, p. 138) literate activity served as a frame for my understanding of how union members came to learn how to compose, circulate, and use texts. This choice for my dissertation was deliberate: to me, it meant that I could continue exploring questions I had encountered as an elected union leader from the perspective of research. This combination blurred the line between conventional divisions between scholarship and service, intellectual and political labor. From my perspective, organizing sharpened my sense of what writing does in the world.
Taking the supposed “traditional” step for me meant focusing on the academic job market as I neared the end of my degree. Entering the 2022-23 academic job market, I encountered the structural constraints many scholars now face: a shrinking number of tenure-track positions, heightened competition, and institutional retrenchment. Put simply: I was not successful in securing a position that year. This moment served as an inflection point for me: try again or find work as an organizer. After conversations with mentors (both at UIUC and IFT), I took up a postdoctoral position with the research team I had been employed with as a graduate student and tried again. When I entered the market a second time, I focused on demonstrating how my scholarship on literate activity in labor contexts can inform pedagogical approaches, particularly in teaching writing as a tool for collective action. At the same time, I could point to my work in the union as evidence of the stakes and broader applicability of that work. This alignment proved critical in securing a position at North Dakota State University, whose job ad specifically called for research and teaching that foregrounded social justice.
What remains most significant across this trajectory is the refusal of a strict hierarchy between studying labor and participating in it. My academic work is sharpened by organizing because it helps me maintain a focus on writing as a sociomaterial practice. In turn, my organizing is strengthened by my research because it brings a set of analytic tools for understanding how texts circulate within complex genre systems like unions. Academic research should not remain passive; rather, I see my work as insights already embedded in ongoing collective efforts. Here, I am reminded of an undated pamphlet distributed by the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) I found in the Walter P. Reuther Digital Archive at Wayne State University. It begins: “Knowledge, like energy, is power only when it is put to work to get good results” (Uncredited, Undated). This quote serves as a frame for how I approach my own work in the academy.
Andy
Andy’s trajectory away from the tenure-track and towards full-time organizing work cannot be understood as a simple departure from one profession to another; rather, it reflects a gradual reorientation of my intellectual and political commitments that often felt in conflict while still in graduate school. This tension can best be seen in comments my PhD advisor made as I worked to both finish coursework and bargain a contract. While the exact quote is lost to memory, I still remember the lament at my lack of focus. I saw my organizing work as directly connected to both my teaching and scholarship. Caring about the working conditions of my colleagues was in my mind what should be focused on. While much of my early professionalization took a familiar path: graduate coursework, participation in scholarly conferences, publication in peer-reviewed journals, and the cultivation of a research agenda legible to a disciplinary audience, this work ran in parallel to my role fighting for better working conditions for my colleagues.
It was within this context that organizing work began to function not as an extracurricular activity but as a parallel site of intellectual and political engagement. Initially, this involvement may have appeared supplementary–serving as a shop steward for my department, helping to envision organizing campaigns, recruiting future leaders to replace me–but over time, organizing came to offer an alternative framework for understanding both my purpose and the best practices of knowledge production. Where academic work often emphasizes individual authorship, specialization, and professional distinction, organizing foregrounds collective action, generalization, and the translation of complex ideas into actional demands. Perhaps surprisingly, my academic training also prepared me well for work as an organizer.
As I continued to organize, I began to question the implicit hierarchy that positions academic scholarship as the primary locus of knowledge production. I love research, and I still participate in the academic conversation despite leaving academia behind, but I came to realize that if I wanted to build the academy my co-author and I often imagined on the page, I would need to do that building work off the page. Likewise, while I learned much from reading the advice and expertise of other scholars, I’ve also learned a lot from my time at the bargaining table and having organizing conversations with my colleagues. By organizing, I encountered forms of knowledge that were both rigorously developed and immediately consequential: strategies for mobilization, analyses of institutional behavior, and practices of coalition-building that required continual adaptation and reflection. Crucially, these forms of knowledge were not ancillary to intellectual life but constituted a mode of theorizing grounded in practice.
As my time in graduate school came to a close, I needed to make a choice. I could finish my dissertation and begin the rigorous process of securing academic employment, or I could take the unexpected path. I had dreamed of being a college professor since age eight, but a new dream was taking shape. The faculty at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign had begun to discuss unionization. I realized I had the skills and expertise necessary to help make the faculty’s dream a concrete reality.
Ultimately, my trajectory underscores the permeability of the boundary between academic and organizing labor, showing that the distinction is less a matter of inherent differences in intellectual rigor than of institutional context and orientation. By moving toward full-time organizing, I continue to participate in the work of broadly reimagining where and how knowledge is produced, validated, and valorized. This reimagining challenges the primacy of the academy, the central site of intellectual life, instead positioning organizing spaces as generative environments in which theory and practice are continually co-constituted. In this sense, the transition is not simply a departure from academia but an expansion of what counts as scholarly work, one that values organizing and intellectual labor equally within the ongoing project of collective transformation and revitalization of higher education.
As you can see from our stories above, academic and organizing work are inherently tied together, just as we have continued to be in our work. Like the helical structure of a DNA strand, our stories of becoming represent different contexts, outcomes, and emphases joining together into one vision of academic and professional life. Put more simply, we could not do this work without each other, nor would we wish to. We argue that such an expansive vision of academic life is the only way forward for academia as a whole.
In 2020, we ended our symposium article advocating for organizing as a practice, writing:
We must build on the work of labor activists in the field and begin to address exploitation by organizing in our own departments, universities, and fields. Small actions, when done collectively, can have ripple effects across our field. Exchanges such as this symposium lay the groundwork for the sustained organizing that can change our field” (Bowman & Kovanen, 2020, p. 5).
As we return to our publication years later, we see how our call was far too narrow. While we maintain that collective action is the path forward, who we see as centrally involved in that work has expanded: we need everyone; everyone needs to be a labor organizer. Further, we argue now that such labor activism is not an ancillary offshoot of one’s professional life but rather a vital aspect to creating an expansive vision of what academia can be and should become.
