Tracing Trajectories
by Andrew Bowman and Bruce Kovanen | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Conclusion
In tracing our trajectories through and alongside the academy, we have argued that the relationship between academic work and labor organizing is not incidental but constitutive. Xchanges served as a vital avenue for developing that perspective on writing and organizing. The unique affordances of Xchanges as a publication specifically for graduate students offered us an opportunity to work with scholars in our field, helping us hone our argument and develop a research trajectory that continues on and through this piece. In both process and product, our Xchanges publication laid the foundation for our future careers. By writing in a venue that not only facilitates early-career publication but also demystifies the often opaque and occluded genres (Swales, 1996) that inform the academic writing process, we were enculturated into that process in a way that taught us to account for reviews and editorial commentary in ways that both satisfy disciplinary expectations and preserved our authorial intent. Writing that initial submission to Xchanges reframed publication not as a singular outcome but as an iterative, dialogic practice embedded within broader networks of scholarly exchange. Simply put, Xchanges is where we developed our academic voices.
If this article (and the Xchanges one before it) make one intervention, it is to challenge readers to reconsider the boundaries that have long structured our understanding of scholarly life: boundaries between research, teaching, and service; intellectual and political labor; individual achievement and collective action. These distinctions, while institutionally reinforced, obscure the degree to which academic work is always already embedded in systems of power. What follows from this recognition is not–we hope–simply a shift in perspective, but also a set of practical reorientations for how academic workers might approach their labor moving forward.
