From Coach to Classroom: Adapting Peer Writing Frameworks for Student-Centered FYC Instruction
by Braydon Dungan | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Introduction
“[A] peer writing coach model…can have a tremendous impact on the student and facilitate writing progress that might otherwise drag out for years.”
Jennifer Wilhite, “Examining the Effectiveness of a Peer Writing Coaching Model” (12)
Fall 2023. I’m starting the second year of my MA program at the University of Louisville. As part of my Graduate Teaching Assistantship, I was scheduled to teach two Introductory Composition courses despite having no former pedagogical training. Yes, I worked in my university’s Academic Writing Center during my first year of the program, but one-on-one conversations as mutual scholarly collaborators hold completely different circumstances than standing in front of a classroom full of open-eyed, ready-to-learn students. In the writing center, sessions were flexible, conversational, and often guided by the writer’s immediate needs; yet, in the classroom, I was expected to lead, instruct, and evaluate. The shift from collaborator to instructor was not as seamless as I had initially imagined. In the spirit of Xchanges’ 25th anniversary—particularly its invitation to “look back” while “writing forward”—this article revisits the collaborative pedagogical commitments of writing center scholarship to consider how such perspectives might inform emerging approaches to First Year Composition (FYC) instruction. My own transition from writing center consultant to classroom instructor provides one site for exploring what those commitments might make possible beyond the writing center.
I remember walking into my classroom during those first few weeks of my second year, feeling the weight of such a stark transition. At just 23 years old—barely older than the age of many of my students—I wasn’t just a student anymore, yet I wasn’t fully an instructor either. I was navigating the liminal space that many Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) occupy, having to simultaneously learn how to teach while actively teaching. Each class session required me to make decisions about how to structure activities, respond to student writing, and position myself in relation to my students. In the writing center, I had the director and assistant director I could consult for advice or assistance; in the classroom though, I felt stranded without a practical framework to guide my pedagogical choices.
It quickly became apparent that while I had been given a generalized theoretical grounding in writing studies, I was still searching for a way to translate that knowledge into something that felt tangible and effective in the classroom. Throughout my years of graduate school thus far—and across two different institutions—I’ve found that this sentiment is commonly shared by many graduate students enrolled in rigorous coursework while also being in charge of their own undergraduate courses. To battle such discord, this article proposes the Teacher Modeling Model (TMM), a pedagogical framework that adapts core principles of peer writing coaching to FYC classrooms. In doing so, it extends writing center scholarship beyond one-on-one tutoring and offers composition instructors—particularly GTAs—a practical framework for making writing processes visible through collective participation.
Composition scholars have long valued the theoretical aspects of pedagogical scholarship while, at times, underemphasizing the practical applications emerging educational professionals often desire. This tension is especially evident for GTAs who are often tasked with leading their own sections of FYC with limited pedagogical training beyond the content knowledge they have developed as students. It’s imperative for our field to maintain an increased focus on GTAs and the work they do educating new and established undergraduate students in writing and reading. While foundational texts such as Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein’s They Say, I Say, Elizabeth Wardle and Doug Downs’ Writing about Writing, and Peter Elbow’s Writing Without Teachers offer important theoretical grounding, they do not always provide the kinds of immediately-transferable frameworks that GTAs can implement into their classrooms. Consequently, many new instructors are forced to navigate the complexities of teaching while also learning how to teach at all.
At the same time, scholarship in writing center studies has long emphasized peer-based models of support. In “Examining the Effectiveness of a Peer Writing Coaching Model,” Jennifer Wilhite demonstrates that peer coaching—where “more advanced peers work with… less experienced writers”— fosters self-advocacy, writerly confidence, and persistence among graduate writers, particularly those navigating complex personal and academic circumstances (4). Rather than positioning the writing coach as an external evaluator, Wilhite’s model emphasizes mutual trust and respect, individualized support, and the collaborative construction of knowledge.
While Wilhite situates her article within graduate writing support, her findings raise important questions about how these peer-oriented frameworks might be adapted beyond the walls of the writing center and into the FYC classroom itself. In line with this special issue’s desire to “look back” while “writing forward”, this article interrogates how Wilhite’s findings and observations can be extended to the context of a FYC classroom. Graduate writing and FYC function within very different composing realities; understanding how the instructor—and, more specifically, the GTA—can best support student writing processes may help deconstruct normative power dynamics in the classroom. When students are treated by their instructor as collaborators rather than traditional “students,” they may feel more comfortable taking risks in their writing.
As I revisited Wilhite’s article, I found myself less interested in reproducing the specific context of peer coaching than in the pedagogical values that made the coaching relationship successful. While graduate writing support and first-year composition differ in important ways, Wilhite’s emphasis on mutual trust, collaborative engagement, and shared writing labor prompted me to ask whether these same principles might reshape classroom instruction if instructors themselves became active participants in the writing process. Building from Wilhite’s peer coaching framework, I introduce the TMM, a pedagogical framework that translates collaborative writing center practices into FYC instruction.
The TMM adopts multiple facets of Wilhite’s peer coaching—including mutuality, flexibility, and collaborative meaning-making—by positioning the instructor as an active participant in the same writing processes students undertake. In turn, the instructor writes alongside students, completes the same scaffolded assignments, and shares their own drafts as a method of modeling and engagement. In doing so, the classroom becomes a site where traditional top-down hierarchies are dismantled and repositioned to maximize student benefit. The TMM does not attempt to recreate Wilhite’s peer coaching model within FYC; rather, it adapts several of its underlying pedagogical commitments to a different instructional environment. Whereas Wilhite examined reciprocal relationships between peer coaches and graduate writers, the TMM explores how similar commitments to collective participation, visible writing processes, and collaborative learning might be extended to instructor-student relationships.
Scholarship on graduate teacher preparation has consistently shown that new instructors often enter the classroom while simultaneously developing their pedagogical identities and instructional practices (Cicchino; Reid et al.; Shepherd et al.). Although these studies have documented the complexities of GTA preparation, they have devoted less attention to practical classroom frameworks that instructors can immediately adapt within their own teaching. The Teacher Modeling Model responds to this need by translating collaborative writing center pedagogies into a flexible instructional framework for first-year composition.
