From Coach to Classroom: Adapting Peer Writing Frameworks for Student-Centered FYC Instruction
by Braydon Dungan | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
From Peer Coaching to Classroom Practice
Scholarship in writing center studies has long emphasized the importance of peer-based support as a means of facilitating writerly development through collaboration instead of top-down evaluation (Harris; Lunsford; North; Wisniewski). Writing is not simply a product to be assessed but a process shaped by social interaction, feedback, and reflection (Baker; Elbow; Warnock). Krista Ratcliffe, in Rhetorical Listening, argues for “a need for listening within rhetoric and composition studies” (23-25), emphasizing that understanding another’s perspective is itself a rhetorical practice. Within writing support, this means tutors and coaches do not simply deliver expertise; rather, they first attend to writers’ goals, concerns, and experiences before collaboratively negotiating meaning. By repositioning coaches as collaborators who write and listen alongside writers as they navigate rhetorical challenges, authority becomes more decentralized, allowing knowledge and meaning to emerge through dialogue rather than instructor-centered evaluation. This article builds on the rich tradition of writing process scholarship that encourages teachers to write with students, illustrating how these similar pedagogical principles can be extended to FYC classrooms led by GTAs and novel instructors.
I often experienced these principles firsthand while working in the Writing Center at the University of Louisville. Writers almost always came prepared with specific tasks to accomplish and physical deliverables to revise, expand, and develop. Rather than arriving to receive instruction, they determined the direction of each session based on their own writerly concerns and goals. In this way, the writer led the session while the tutor took a backseat. Rather than serving as the sole facilitator of instruction, the writing coach responded to the writer’s immediate needs by asking questions, offering feedback, and collaboratively working through writing challenges. What struck me most about these interactions was not simply the effectiveness of the feedback itself but the relationship that emerged through collective engagement with the writing process. Those experiences ultimately prompted me to consider whether similar pedagogical commitments could exist beyond the writing center and within FYC classrooms.
Wilhite’s study of her peer coaching model offers an especially pertinent articulation of such dynamics reflected in my writing center experiences. In her work with women graduate writers, Wilhite demonstrates how individualized support can foster not only improvements in writing but also increased confidence, persistence, and self-advocacy. Rather than positioning the coach as an evaluator, she describes coaching as a flexible and responsive relationship in which support is continually adapted to writers’ immediate goals, concerns, and evolving needs. Importantly, Wilhite explains that the coaching model itself was “co-developed” through the coach’s expertise alongside participants’ needs and suggestions (11). As the coaching relationships developed, they created opportunities for encouragement, celebration, emotional support, and frank conversations about fear, anxiety, and feelings of impostor syndrome. In this way, writing support emerged from participants’ authentic lived experiences rather than from predetermined instructional practices.
Despite the longstanding efficacy of peer coaching within writing center contexts, these pedagogical approaches have remained largely institutionally separated from FYC classrooms. Writing centers typically function as sites of supplementary support, while classroom instruction continues to operate within different structures of authority, assessment, and scale. This distinction raises an important question: what might happen if the collaborative pedagogical commitments of peer coaching were adapted for everyday classroom instruction? The Teacher Modeling Model responds to this question by translating Wilhite’s emphasis on flexibility, collective participation, and shared vulnerability into a framework designed specifically for FYC. Rather than reproducing peer coaching within the classroom, the TMM demonstrates one way that writing center pedagogies can extend beyond the writing center and into everyday teaching practices while acknowledging the unique responsibilities, constraints, and challenges of classroom instruction.
