|

From Coach to Classroom: Adapting Peer Writing Frameworks for Student-Centered FYC Instruction

by Braydon Dungan | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Walking the Walk: Implementing the TMM

Part of the reason I wanted to share this strategy is because I’ve witnessed the effects of implementing the TMM myself. In my Intermediate Composition course I taught in the Fall 2025 semester, I had a course structure where students wrote an essay in each of our course’s three units: the discourse analysis, the literacy narrative, and the research essay. For each unit, students were required to submit three drafts to encourage process-oriented pedagogies: the Shitty First Draft—akin to Anne Lamott’s landmark work—the 2nd Draft, and the Final Draft. The final unit of the course centered on a research essay that students completed through a sequence of scaffolded assignments. Rather than asking students to immediately begin drafting the essay, the unit guided them through several low-stakes activities that gradually built toward the final product. Among these scaffolded assignments were two separate activities: the Research Rationale and the Corpus Building Exercise. Together, these assignments prepared students for drafting the larger research essay while also becoming ideal sites for implementing the TMM. By completing the same assignments alongside my students, I engaged in the same composing processes while simultaneously evaluating the effectiveness of my own scaffolding. This section illustrates how the TMM functions in practice by demonstrating how collective participation reshaped assignment design, classroom interactions, and ongoing pedagogical revision throughout a FYC course.

Near the end of teaching my Intermediate Composition course in Fall 2025, I began to notice how physically and emotionally drained my students had become. Their faces—eager, bright, and animated at the start of the term—had turned pale, unmoving, and stoic. I realized that many students were balancing demanding workloads across their other courses, and the stress of the mid-semester grind—a period GTAs know all too well—was beginning to affect their well-being. They weren’t the only ones feeling this pressure; I, too, had become overwhelmed by the heightened responsibilities that accompany the end of the semester. I knew I needed to do something differently, or both my students and I would lose even more motivation to engage with such a demanding writing project. This collective sense of fatigue created a pedagogical challenge which prompted me to reconsider how students were engaging with the course.

In my experiences teaching, and through my conversations with students, one of their biggest frustrations with process-oriented writing pedagogies is that some process work can seem irrelevant or, as they term it, like “busy work.” If students feel as if the assignments they’re completing are not effective or pertinent to them, they’re much more likely to not put adequate labor into their drafting. In line with my desire to have students write an essay which could be transferred beyond the classroom as a professional material, I wanted students to truly care about the scaffolding assignments they would complete in the composition of the research essay. I decided the best way to illustrate the efficacy of the assignments I created would be to participate alongside my students: I wouldn’t just talk the talk, but I’d now be walking the walk too.

I specifically would like to draw attention to two assignments where I found mutual learning and collective motivation to be most present during the TMM. The first I will discuss is the Research Rationale. This assignment—assigned during the first week of the unit—is a step-by-step activity encouraging students to draft a justification for writing their research essay. In this assignment, students explained their own connection to the chosen topic and why their selection would help them maintain interest across the final unit. Such an assignment encourages students to get words onto the page, as Lamott suggests, serving as a springboard for the initial drafting stages of the essay. The second assignment was a similar activity which guided students through their initial research. I call this assignment the Corpus Building Exercise. In this assignment, students were required to spend time scouring the Internet for secondary sources to help address their research topic. In building this corpus, students were also required to provide a brief annotation and MLA citation for the source. As a result, by the end of the exercise, students had a corpus of 3–5 secondary sources to ground their essay in.

Both of these assignments—the Research Rationale and the Corpus Building Exercise—provided students the time to engage in transferable labor with direct applications to drafting the essay. These low-stakes activities also became important moments for implementing the TMM because they made the composing process visible in ways that traditional instruction alone could not. Informally, several students commented that seeing my own drafts helped them better understand how my written directions translated into actual rhetorical choices. For students who struggled to interpret assignment prompts through written instructions alone, the instructor model provided a concrete example of how those expectations could take shape in practice. Rather than replacing instruction, the modeling complemented it by making the writing process more transparent and accessible.

In joining students as they completed this work, I was able to better understand what was working and what wasn’t working for each assignment. For example, during the Rationale, I initially had a minimum word requirement of 300 words; as I completed my own Rationale, I noticed it was difficult to reach that 300-word mark. Consequently, I announced to the class that the word count would be flexible, and they could instead aim for 225–250 words. This moment exemplifies the TMM’s emphasis on reflective pedagogical revision, showing students a central premise of the TMM: instructor participation does not simply model writing for students, but it also creates opportunities for instructors to critically evaluate and revise their own pedagogical materials as composing unfolds. Rather than waiting until the end of the semester to reflect on assignment efficacy, the TMM positions pedagogical revision as an ongoing component of collaborative participation.

It’s also essential for me to describe my physical placement during these two assignments, as it is a vital component of the TMM. Even what might seem like minor classroom practices—such as physical positioning or patterns of interaction—can shape student comfort and accessibility, especially for those navigating different cultural expectations or trauma responses (Tayles 309). By reconsidering these practices, instructors can create environments that are more responsive to a wider range of student needs.

To respond to the varying experiences of students, I physically positioned myself in a desk at the front of the room right beside another empty desk that students could sit in if they had a question. In doing this, I was pulling from my writing center training and experience at the University of Louisville. By physically sitting at a desk, I was mirroring students’ own positioning in their seats. I was creating a rift in the traditional power imbalance inherent to the classroom. By leaving a desk beside me empty, I was visually inviting students to seek my guidance without forcing them to talk about their work and putting them on the spot.

Many students walked up and sat beside me, bringing their computers so we could look at their assignment together. As students showed me their own work, I mirrored this behavior by showing portions of my own writing where I either shared a commonality with the student or I differed from their approach. Rather than just talking the talk, I was also walking the walk by mutually learning with the student about each other’s writing processes and approaches. Once the assignment was due, I shared a course announcement where I included a running Google Doc of all the assignments I was completing with students. That way, if students wanted to see what I was working on, how I was approaching the process-oriented assignments, if my writing could serve as a moment of brainstorming, or something else, they had complete access to my own work, just as I had complete access to theirs. I was decentralizing the power imbalance of the classroom both physically, socially, and pedagogically.