|

From Coach to Classroom: Adapting Peer Writing Frameworks for Student-Centered FYC Instruction

by Braydon Dungan | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Identity, Power, and the GTA Classroom

In detailing such a strategy, it’s important to foreground my own identity within this discussion since the TMM encourages the exploration of one’s identity. Its focus on identity also mirrors the TMM’s goal of facilitating authentic connections while deconstructing the top-down power dynamics many university classrooms possess. Oftentimes in college classrooms, the lecturer utilizes their dominant role to establish unequal power structures and social relationships (Fajar and Nadhillah 64-65). Because the TMM asks instructors to become visible participants in the writing process, questions of identity and authority become central to the framework.

This attention to GTA positionality builds upon previous conversations regarding graduate student identity. Al Harahap and Brian Hendrickson challenge current disciplinary narratives that position graduate students solely as teachers-in-training; rather, they argue for greater attention to the distinct identities and institutional conditions graduate students navigate. Similarly, Amanda Presswood and Virginia Schwarz extend this notion by emphasizing the idea that graduate students develop their own professional identities while simultaneously negotiating the labor and material demands of graduate education. These conversations are especially relevant to the TMM because the framework asks instructors to consider how their own identities and positionalities shape their participation in the classroom. For GTAs in particular, engaging in this type of reflection acknowledges the complex position of occupying coexisting roles of a student, instructor, and developing scholar.

I approach this discussion as a GTA myself. I’m a 26-year-old white male who identifies as part of the LGBTQ+ community. I come from a long line of public educators, and I’ve been exposed to teaching and pedagogy for as long as I can remember. I foreground my positionality not as a brief moment in my article but as a central tenet to the pedagogical commitments of the TMM. Identity, in this model, is not separate from instruction; rather, it shapes how authority is enacted and negotiated within the classroom. Traditional classroom structures often position the instructor as the primary wielder of knowledge, thus reinforcing systemic hierarchical relationships that can inhibit authentic engagement (Fajar and Nadhillah). To work against traditional notions of power in the classroom, the TMM seeks to redistribute authority by inviting instructors to work alongside students and making visible both the processes and anxieties inherent in writing.

Power, then, becomes a central concern of this model. In FYC classrooms, the negotiation of authority between students and instructors significantly impacts student engagement, retention, and their willingness to take risks in their writing. By analyzing power structures, themes of authority and resistance come to the forefront of examination which helps ascertain how students may be negatively impacted if the power of the instructor greatly outweighs the power of the student (Syahriani et al. 66). Since writing asks students to publicly share unfinished ideas, receive critique, and continually revise their thinking, classroom authority becomes especially consequential. Laura Micciche in Doing Emotion, highlights how “writing involves sticky attachments… that find their way onto the page sometimes against our will” (106). Students’ willingness to experiment, revise, and take rhetorical risks is shaped not only by assignment design but by how instructors enact their authority throughout the writing process to engage with such “sticky attachments”. The TMM responds to these concerns by encouraging a circulation of power within the classroom, one which encourages instructors to model vulnerability and active participation as co-writers. In doing so, the model not only provides GTAs with a practical, transferable pedagogical framework, but it also reimagines the FYC classroom as a space where learning is co-constructed rather than hierarchical. For new and emerging composition instructors, this power circulation between students and instructor will better illustrate the instructor’s commitment to mutual learning and success.

Furthermore, the TMM does not simply redistribute classroom power by asking instructors to complete the same writing tasks as their students. It also reimagines how pedagogical authority is produced; rather than treating course design as a fixed structure determined solely by the instructor, the framework recognizes that effective pedagogy emerges through continual interaction with students. Like Wilhite’s peer coaching model, which was co-developed through the peer coach’s expertise and their participants’ evolving needs, the TMM similarly evolves through instructors’ experiences writing alongside their students and responding to the insights those shared experiences produce. Classroom authority, then, is not relinquished but made more collaborative, reflexive, and responsive to the realities of student writing.

Ultimately, the TMM recognizes that effective writing pedagogy is not simply delivered by instructors but continually shaped through regular interactions with students. Like Wilhite’s peer coaching model, the TMM also develops through the shared experiences of instructors and students writing alongside one another. Rather than positioning students solely as recipients of top-down instruction, this framework acknowledges their experiences, questions, and responses as valuable contributors to pedagogical development. Hence, authority is not diminished but rather reimagined as a collaborative act, allowing both teaching and learning to become co-constructed within the FYC classroom.