|

From Coach to Classroom: Adapting Peer Writing Frameworks for Student-Centered FYC Instruction

by Braydon Dungan | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

The Teacher Modeling Model (TMM): A Pedagogical Framework

Building on these collaborative pedagogical commitments, the Teacher Modeling Model (TMM) offers one way to translate such approaches into the composition classroom. The TMM is a model where the instructor of the classroom positions themselves as a mutual learner alongside students. Throughout this article, I refer to the TMM as a pedagogical framework rather than simply a teaching strategy or classroom activity. In using the term “framework”, I mean an overall set of principles which guides instructional decision-making across multiple classroom contexts rather than prescribing a single instructional technique.

Whereas pedagogical theories often explain why learning occurs and individual classroom activities illustrate how particular objectives are accomplished, the TMM provides instructors with a flexible structure for making decisions about participation, modeling, authority, and collaboration throughout the writing process. Since writing often develops through recursive drafting, revision, reflection, and social interaction, instructors frequently make ongoing decisions about how visible their own writing practices should become within the classroom. Consequently, the TMM is designed to guide those decisions by organizing them around collective participation and collaborative learning rather than around instructor-centered evaluation.

Within the TMM, this collaborative philosophy is operationalized by asking instructors to participate in the same composing processes they ask of students. The work that the TMM asks students to complete—drafting, reflecting, researching, revising—becomes work that the instructor also completes. To do this, the instructor may periodically complete the same activities students engage with and the same readings students are assigned, thus working toward the same final deliverable as their students. In doing so, instructors make their own composing practices visible while simultaneously experiencing the same challenges that students encounter throughout the writing process. This approach extends Wilhite’s (2022) framing of peer support as a space of mutual “encouragement, celebration, and motivation” into the FYC classroom.

For example, if an Introductory Composition class is assigned a literacy narrative, the instructor would also write their own literacy narrative alongside their students. Not only would this serve as a running model students could use for inspiration, but it would also allow the instructor—especially a novel instructor or GTA—to understand firsthand what is working in the assignments they assign and what could be improved. As Peter Elbow argues in Writing Without Teachers, writing is “a transaction with other people” (76). By participating in that transaction alongside students, instructors experience their own assignments, prompts, and scaffolding from the perspective of a writer rather than solely as the designer of instruction. Doing so can reveal unclear expectations, ineffective scaffolding, or rhetorical challenges that might otherwise remain unnoticed. Consequently, instructors are better positioned to refine course materials in ways that are more accessible and responsive to students’ composing experiences. With the TMM, I am proposing an approach in which the composition instructor positions themselves as an active contributor to course scaffolding. If students are asked to post to a discussion board, the instructor also contributes as a participant. If students submit a working draft to demonstrate their progress, the instructor likewise shares a draft that remains visibly in progress.

While the TMM was developed through my experiences as a Graduate Teaching Assistant and is particularly well-suited to new composition instructors, its underlying principles can be adapted across a range of pedagogical contexts. The degree to which instructors implement the TMM, however, should be informed by the material realities of their teaching environments. GTAs and instructors with relatively-low teaching demands will find the TMM to be quite transferable into their classrooms. On the other hand, for instructors with a heavy teaching schedule such as three to five sections of FYC each semester, it may not be feasible to complete every assignment alongside students. In these contexts, instructors might instead selectively implement the TMM during major assignments, newly-developed units, or scaffolded activities where visible modeling is likely to have the greatest pedagogical impact.

In other words, the TMM should be understood less as a prescriptive requirement than as a pedagogical orientation. Its central premise is not that instructors must complete every task students complete, but that strategically participating in the writing process can make composing practices more visible, foster collaborative learning, and provide instructors with opportunities to evaluate and refine their own pedagogical materials.