BP & Sombrero Meme Deepfakes: Revisiting the Ethics of Synthetic Media in the Age of AI
by Cat Hubka & Athena C. Gordon | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Introduction
In an era defined by rapid advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI), the production and circulation of synthetic media have become central concerns for scholars, educators, technical and professional communicators, and publics alike. Generative AI technologies now enable the creation of images and videos ranging from innocuous visual memes to highly realistic deepfakes—synthetic media depicting individuals doing or saying things they never did or said. These technological capabilities have created opportunities for creative expression and streamlined many aspects of communication. At the same time, they have also strained foundational principles of ethical communication, including truthfulness, accuracy, respect for persons, and accountability. The core ethical commitments that have guided Technical and Professional Communication (TPC) for decades remain relevant even as tools evolve, but they are increasingly tested in contexts where the boundaries between “real” and “synthetic” blur and where audiences struggle to distinguish objective evidence from fabricated content. This tension is not limited to malicious or deceptive uses of AI. Even in human-generated photography, the visual impact can trigger assumptions of artificiality, as seen in coverage of South African photographer Kyle Goetsch’s night-sky and wildlife images that audiences initially mistook for AI-generated work—a reminder that perceptions of authenticity have become as ethically salient as the technologies themselves (Bantock & Cross, 2026). Such reactions reveal how expectations shaped by AI’s visual aesthetics now influence viewers’ interpretation of imagery.
However, recent high-profile examples show how AI-generated content can change public discussion. In U.S. political communication, a phenomenon called “slopaganda” has emerged—official social media posts that mix memes, tropes, and synthetic images to provoke reactions and sway perceptions. For instance, crude sombrero-meme deepfake videos showing prominent congressional leaders wearing Mexican stereotype imagery spread widely on social media during a government shutdown, drawing sharp criticism for its racist implications and misleading depiction (Walker, 2025). These clips, circulated by well-known political figures, used digitally altered visuals to shape a partisan narrative, exploiting cultural stereotypes and emotional responses rather than presenting information. The “sombrero memes” demonstrate how superficial humor and symbolic imagery can intersect with political influence to create content that is technically AI-generated yet ethically questionable in its respect for dignity and civic duty. Beyond political memes, heavily altered representations of real-world events pose serious challenges to the public’s understanding of reality. Recently, AI-altered images and videos have circulated around violent incidents, such as the Minneapolis shooting of RenĂ©e Good involving federal agents, fueling widespread misinformation that makes it harder to determine what really happened (Gilbert, 2026). These artificial visuals, often shared without clear signs of their inauthenticity, increase confusion and greatly hinder audiences’ ability to interpret evidence.
Because Xchanges engages with emerging scholars who discuss technology’s role in interdisciplinary communication, the Special 25th Anniversary Issue provides a timely opportunity to revisit scholarship at an especially fraught moment. McDonnell’s (2015) article, “The Ethics of Visual Rhetoric & Photo Manipulation,” foreshadowed today’s challenges with AI image generation, deepfakes, and automated text production because the ethical dilemma it outlines—how to represent reality responsibly under institutional pressure—has surfaced ferociously in today’s communication environments. We call on technical communicators to take an active role in shaping communication practices in the context of emerging technologies, specifically AI. Our ethical responsibility has expanded, not diminished, in today’s TPC environments. Rather than treating AI as a rupture in communication practices, we assert that it is simply the latest iteration of a longer history of representational mediation, in which practitioners’ agency, roles, and responsibility have expanded.
