BP & Sombrero Meme Deepfakes: Revisiting the Ethics of Synthetic Media in the Age of AI
by Cat Hubka & Athena C. Gordon | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Situating Virtue Ethics
While there have been different definitions of ethics in TPC (Markel, 1994; Ross, 2025), we find it most useful to understand how people can use ethics as a decision-making tool to make responsible decisions in their communications. We argue that virtue ethics in particular is a useful framework to guide ethical communicative practices in the age of AI. According to Aristotle, the moral use of rhetoric is rooted in virtues, which are character dispositions to behave in “good” ways. Aristotle writes, “virtues are necessarily a good; for those having them are well-off in regard to them, and virtues are productive of good things and matters of action” (Kennedy, 1991, p. 63). Further, Aristotle specifies that virtue (areté), intelligence (phronesis), and goodwill (eunoia) are all necessary for establishing the speaker’s good character (ethos) (Herrick, 2021). Therefore, this virtue is necessary for establishing credibility as a rhetor, as well as for practicing morally good rhetoric. Without virtue, the speaker is dishonest and dishonorable.
Academics and practitioners engage in ethical communication practices when they reflect on their moral habits and values and examine how morality is “reflected in them” (Vallor, 2026, p. 24). This engagement with virtue ethics, or decision-making based on virtue, promotes a culture of responsibility in moral decision-making. Rather than focusing on universal rules or isolated decisions, virtue ethics illuminates how ethical decisions are formed over time in pursuit of virtue and emphasizes that repeated opportunities for action shape our character (Holmes, 2025). With the recognition that too much or too little of virtues is not wise in all situations, virtue ethics calls for people to look for “practical wisdom in between extremes” (Holmes, 2025, p. 87). For example, solely valuing limited virtues, such as expediency, causes harm and functions as a vice. In his famous essay analyzing a technical memo from the Holocaust, Katz (1992) critiques how Aristotle’s descriptions of deliberative rhetoric prioritized expediency as “the primary virtue” and that this narrow focus on expediency has promoted mass extermination and dehumanization (p.267). Complex and evolving ethical situations require additional ethical perspectives beyond an ethic of expediency to engage in humane decision-making.
The concept of virtue ethics from classical rhetoric has influenced the TPC community’s perspective on making rhetorical decisions that align with our values. Throughout TPC scholarship, virtue ethics has been applied to emerging technologies, such as analyzing digital rhetoric during times of change (Colton & Holmes, 2016) and promoting app design that challenges and prevents oppressive beauty standards (Wang & Gu, 2022). Virtue ethics promotes a shift in communication cultures by grounding the decision-making process in virtues such as honesty, patience, and goodwill. This is especially useful for a flexible and sustainable way to respond to complex and evolving ethical dilemmas across different TPC environments. In Ethical Design Intelligence: The Virtuous Designer, d’Anjou (2020) draws on Aristotle’s ethical philosophy of virtue to examine how designers across disciplines can consider how virtuous design practice can define moral responses to situations and develop individual responsibility for choices. Virtue design ethics examines the teleological nature of design and the meaning of happiness at the end of design practice. This existential inquiry helps designers and communicators make intentional, sustainable decisions by reflecting on their character amid constant social, political, and environmental change. In addition, the development of virtues within a community, such as a global technosocial virtue ethic in relation to AI challenges, has the potential to resonate with diverse people across cultures due to its flexibility in addressing evolving moral challenges (Vallor, 2016).
Considering our responsibility to engage in socially just communication, Holmes (2025) suggests that the TPC community can incorporate virtues from marginalized global cultures to promote collective care. For example, Ubuntu, a normative ethical approach used on the African continent, calls for interdependence, solidarity, and civic responsibility, centering the community and humanity as important in the pursuit of a good life (Walwema, 2025). To address the ethical challenges of AI technology, Walwema (2025) suggests that ubuntu can serve as a “mediating force” to redress marginalization by algorithms and restore justice (p. 196).
In our pursuit of the “good life,” we must identify virtues that we aspire to engage in as habits, which may include care, honesty, citizenry, equity, and justice. This virtue ethics thinking helps situate the self in society and reveal the dispositions of the technical communicator (Duffy et al., 2018). We understand that the field of technical communication reproduces and creates “problematic sites of injustice” (Walton et al., 2019, p. 1), and that social justice perspectives are necessary to legitimize and redefine the field of TPC (Jones, 2016; Savage, 2018; Walton et al., 2019). Indeed, as Jones (2016) posits, TPC work is not neutral or apolitical and has many values embedded in the work. We believe that virtue ethics frameworks help us build critical reflexivity, an active and ongoing process of self-reflection and action, which is necessary to engage in a socially just communication practice (Agboka, 2025; Walton et al., 2019).
