|

BP & Sombrero Meme Deepfakes: Revisiting the Ethics of Synthetic Media in the Age of AI

by Cat Hubka & Athena C. Gordon | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Affirming Our Professional Responsibility

Xchanges 25th special anniversary issue provides an opportunity to reimagine our professional responsibility, re-anchor ethical frameworks, and respond to contemporary challenges. Because AI technologies will continue to evolve, ethical considerations must evolve alongside them. The recommendations that follow are offered not as definitive solutions but as a framework for ongoing reflection and action, calling on communicators to exercise their agency, rely on their moral compass, and intentionally shape ethical communication practices in an ever-changing technological landscape.

Given the rise of AI-enabled communication technologies, technical communicators today have more power and responsibility than ever. Therefore, TPC communicators must make intentional choices to do good and mitigate the harms of AI, promoting a culture of ethical responsibility. To ensure that AI is designed for the betterment of the community, TPC designers should promote inclusive technology design, particularly with minoritized groups who are often excluded from conversations (Colón Vargas, 2025) and with interdisciplinary stakeholders (Panarese et al., 2015). By seeking professional development to improve their AI literacy and understanding of bias, TPC practitioners are empowered to use AI responsibly in their roles (Zhang & Lee, 2025) and intentionally use AI in their practice to reflect on what is lost when using AI rather than human agents. Belance et al. (2024) propose that “practitioners should account for the dehumanization process derived from the automation of service” (p.164). It’s important for TPC communicators to reject the notion of technology as a neutral force and recognize the value of individual and collective virtues that humanize communication in this era of technological growth.

Many argue that TPC educators are on the front lines of teaching AI literacy (Balart & Shryock, 2024; Gallagher et al., 2025; Getto et al., 2025; Raji et al., 2021; Tham, 2024; Usher et al., 2025). In the classroom, TPC educators should explore the use of AI, and text and image production to help students–and themselves–unpack their values and ethics. Pedagogically, this can include activities and assignments that support students’ discovery not only of the tools but also to critically analyze the effects of the artifacts generated. And, during the assessment of student work, the central activity can fundamentally change from “Is the learner cheating by using AI?” to “What is the student learning by using AI, how are the learner’s ethical values guiding their use of it, and how will the artifact produced affect its intended audiences?” Reflection, then, becomes a necessary part of activities and assignments to help students and educators uncover and articulate their own ethical systems and values—and consider the impact of their rhetorical choices co-created with AI on their audiences. For example, the sombrero meme could serve as a model of study and thus become a valuable pedagogical tool to help students unpack their own ethical values with respect to messaging and AI use.

We posit that this kind of pedagogical approach is best supported in writing programs that embrace virtue ethics, too. The central task now facing Writing Program Administrators (WPAs) is not implementing expanded plagiarism policies—though some would argue it is a key task—but rather, reframing AI use and its artifacts as a literacy that combines critical thinking about the tools with discussions and reflections about the learner’s ethical frameworks and interpretations of its artifacts. In other words, WPAs should steer TPC instructors away from policing student work and toward pedagogies of AI literacy and conversations that emphasize ethical responsibilities, not just as users of the tools but as humans communicating with other humans.

Likewise, TPC educators in the disciplines now have the responsibility to help students consider ethics not just as an ancillary professional obligation understood through a case study, such as Volkswagen’s 2015 “Dieselgate” (Hotten, 2015). Instead, TPC educators in the disciplines should infuse ethical inquiry into all writing activities. In the hegemonic discourse conventions of STEM disciplines, this is particularly important. Typically, “clear and concise” prose is emphasized, marginalizing English Language Learners who may turn to AI to generate their documents. However, this sends a message: the learner doesn’t learn to compose “clear and concise prose” if they become over-reliant on AI tools, and it perpetuates hegemonic language power systems (Colón Vargas, 2025). TPC educators in this domain, then, face layered challenges regarding AI literacy, artifact production, and ethics. Virtue ethics provides a more nuanced, personal framework for STEM learners as they enter the discourses of their chosen field.

Ethical responsibility is a personal, intentional choice, and we will digress for a moment to share an anecdote that illustrates our point. One administrator at our institution often reflects on the proliferation of synthetic media in our workspace and states that “the human touch is so important,” remembering that behind every technology, there needs to be people who govern its appropriate use, engage in critical thinking, and communicate compassionately. When she engages with technology, she thinks about how she can bring her humanity into the work and how her work has real consequences for students, for better or worse. This is an approach to TPC communication that models the importance of personal ethical reflection. We must consider how our communications, directly and indirectly, impact our local and global communities, and take action to ensure that our humanity is not lost amid technological advancement. This is a key takeaway of responsible TPC. We cannot lose our own ethical judgment as humans in times of change.

Ultimately, ethical communication cannot be delegated to technology. As synthetic media become increasingly integrated into TPC practice, the central ethical question is not whether AI is inherently good or bad, but whether communicators cultivate the character and practical wisdom needed to use these tools responsibly. By centering moral agency on the human communicator, virtue ethics reminds us that technologies may influence communication, but they do not absolve individuals of responsibility for the choices they make or the values those choices reflect. This perspective, in combination with other ethical frameworks, offers an important foundation for TPC’s future. In practice, virtue ethics encourages communicators to cultivate habits of reflection, transparency, accountability, and discernment that foster thoughtful engagement with AI rather than uncritical adoption. In pedagogy, it shifts educational priorities beyond technical proficiency to include the cultivation of ethical judgment, preparing students to navigate emerging technologies with integrity and competence. For scholarship, a virtue ethics framework invites researchers to move beyond evaluating the capabilities or risks of AI systems alone and to examine how communicators develop, sustain, and enact virtuous practices in AI-mediated environments. As technologies continue to evolve, so too must our ethical frameworks. We need to engage in an enduring ethical orientation by grounding decision-making within the character habits of those who design, deploy, and communicate with AI tools. In so doing, it offers not a static set of rules but a continuing call for technical communicators to exercise their agency intentionally to shape the future of AI-enabled communication in ways that advance both professional excellence and the public good.