BP & Sombrero Meme Deepfakes: Revisiting the Ethics of Synthetic Media in the Age of AI
by Cat Hubka & Athena C. Gordon | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Applying Virtue Ethics
While McDonnell does not explicitly discuss virtue ethics in her article, we believe it is another useful framework for evaluating whether digitally altered media, whether produced with Photoshop or AI tools, is ethical. McDonnell discusses principles of honesty and public responsibility, which we consider virtues important in TPC. In her analysis of BP’s photo manipulation, McDonnell broadens the ethical discussion beyond mere accuracy, drawing on scholarship that argues visuals should prioritize clear, informative content over aesthetic qualities. When decorative or persuasive elements hinder truthful representation, ethical limits are crossed. Ethical visual communication, therefore, involves balancing accuracy, audience impact, and rhetorical purpose. Thus, McDonnell concludes that BP’s actions were unethical because they altered reality and misled audiences, violating principles of honesty and public responsibility. Although all visuals involve some form of mediation, intentional manipulation that distorts truth undermines ethical communication. Her final argument is that technical communicators must recognize their rhetorical power and stay accountable for how their visual choices influence audiences, especially when under pressure.
This is especially important in the age of AI. One challenge is the prevalence and influence of synthetic media that impact our public values, sometimes in insidious ways. Research into deepfakes shows that these highly realistic manipulations can influence beliefs and judgments even after audiences have been explicitly told that the material is fake. In controlled experiments, participants exposed to deepfake videos continued to respond to the content in their subsequent judgments—even when they knew the videos were AI-generated and marked as such. This illustrates cognitive persistence, in which visual realism influences belief in ways that go beyond rational correction, challenging the idea that transparency alone is enough to safeguard against deception (Clark & Lewandowsky, 2025). This study demonstrates that technological sophistication and psychological reactions to synthetic content present significant challenges for democratic communication and public trust. However, these challenges do not indicate a fundamental shift from traditional communication ethics. Indeed, they highlight the need to rearticulate and adapt enduring ethical communication virtues for the digital age of AI. The TPC community can use virtue ethics to establish shared values regarding the use of AI tools and generated media, such as honesty and accountability. This grounding in virtues can facilitate critical, intentional reflection on communication habits, aligning communicative choices with virtues.
For example, in political communication, such as the viral sombrero deepfake memes, communicators have a responsibility to consider how their communication reflects their character and moral habits. These AI-generated memes were created and circulated during the 2025 United States government shutdown to assert power and dominance during a time of ideological division. Memes showed multiple Democratic representatives, including Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer, with sombreros and mustaches, accompanied by mariachi music. During this moment in the shutdown, Republican leaders claimed that Democrats were trying to fund healthcare for undocumented immigrants, which Democratic leaders denied (Walker, 2025). These memes mocked Democratic leaders and perpetuated racist caricatures and stereotypes about the Mexican-American community. The effects were inflammatory; the memes incited conservative supporters of the administration and alienated democrats, Mexican-Americans, and nonpartisan constituents. During a government shutdown, building consensus across party lines is necessary and involves some degree of unity among lawmakers. Considering the virtue of unity, these sombrero memes are unethical as they alienate the Mexican-American community and create further division across party lines. These memes also convey the communicator’s character. With the goal of virtue ethics aimed at the pursuit of the “good life,” the communicative act of creating and distributing sombrero memes does not reflect habits that will lead to a “good life.” In a virtue ethics framework, these memes should not have been produced or distributed because they didn’t reflect well on the AI content creators.
Virtue ethics calls for us to reflect on our habits and values during decision-making, which we believe is an important ethical approach to synthetic media. We should consider what kind of character we want to reflect and intentionally pursue virtues, such as honesty, patience, justice, and care, in our everyday interactions with AI. This connection to virtues helps us approach ethical challenges with flexibility to respond to different situations in TPC. We are responsible in our pursuit of “the good life” to use AI in ways that align with our virtues.
