|

BP & Sombrero Meme Deepfakes: Revisiting the Ethics of Synthetic Media in the Age of AI

by Cat Hubka & Athena C. Gordon| Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Implementing an Ethical Approach

Using the case study of the 2010 BP oil spill, McDonnell argues that while visual rhetoric is an inherently powerful and unavoidable tool in technical and professional communication, its ethical use is more complex than simply distinguishing between honesty and deception. McDonnell’s thesis is that ethical decision-making in visual communication must consider the mediated nature of images, the persuasive power of visuals, and the situational pressures communicators face. Despite this complexity, altering visuals in ways that distort reality ultimately violates core ethical principles.

She starts her argument by highlighting the persuasive power of visual rhetoric, noting that images—such as photographs, graphs, and technical illustrations—shape how audiences perceive and interpret information across different contexts. She emphasizes that visuals are never neutral representations of reality; rather, they are always shaped by technological and human choices such as framing, angles, and editing. This makes the idea of “truth” in images more complex because even unedited photos involve some level of selective representation. To explore these ethical issues, McDonnell examines BP’s use of manipulated images after the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. The company changed photographs to show a more controlled and effective response effort, which initially appears to be a clear ethical violation. However, McDonnell complicates this view by considering the intense pressures from corporations, the public, and the media that influence decision-making. She asserts that ethical evaluation involves not only looking at the act of manipulation but also considering the rhetorical situation in which communicators operate.

McDonnell raises ethical questions about how to balance honesty and institutional image in public communications, particularly in cases of photo manipulation. McDonnell (2015) asks us to think: “Where do we draw the line in terms of reality mediation and persuasion?” (p. 5). And to help us better understand where these ethical boundaries lie, she guides readers through two ethical frameworks, deontology and consequentialism, that can be applied to BP’s photo manipulation to determine whether BP’s actions were justified. We believe that these two frameworks can be useful for exploring AI-generated content and that additional frameworks, such as virtue ethics, are necessary for TPC practitioners and educators to navigate the specific complexities of AI-generated visual media.

Rather than locating the primary ethical problem of synthetic media in the technology itself, this article argues that the more significant concern lies in how humans choose to employ these tools. Artificial intelligence is increasingly invoked as an explanation—or even a justification—for questionable communication practices, allowing users to shift responsibility onto the technology. Such framing risks positioning AI as a scapegoat for unethical decisions while obscuring the fact that communicators remain the moral agents responsible for the messages they produce. Although recent scholarship has characterized AI as a communicative co-agent capable of shaping rhetorical outcomes, the presence of AI in the writing process does not diminish the human user’s ethical accountability. AI may imitate language, generate persuasive content, and influence communicative products, but it does not possess moral agency. By definition, a tool cannot bear ethical responsibility in the same way as a human actor. Consequently, ethical evaluation of synthetic media should remain centered on the character, judgment, and intentions of the communicator who chooses how, when, and why to incorporate AI into communication practices.

This emphasis on human agency makes virtue ethics particularly well-suited to examining the ethical challenges posed by synthetic media. Unlike ethical frameworks that primarily evaluate actions according to rules or outcomes, virtue ethics asks what kind of person a communicator becomes through repeated habits and decisions. In the context of AI-assisted communication, this perspective encourages practitioners to move beyond viewing themselves as passive users of increasingly capable technologies and instead recognize themselves as moral actors whose choices shape both professional practice and public discourse. The widespread accessibility of synthetic media heightens the consequences of communicative decisions, making reflection on virtues such as honesty, integrity, prudence, accountability, and practical wisdom especially important. By cultivating these virtues through habitual practice, communicators can engage AI critically rather than unreflectively, ensuring that technological efficiency does not supersede ethical judgment. In this way, virtue ethics recenters the distinctly human capacities for reflection, deliberation, and moral responsibility that remain essential even as communication technologies become more sophisticated.

At the same time, virtue ethics should not be understood as the sole framework for evaluating AI-mediated communication. The ethical complexities introduced by synthetic media benefit from multiple complementary perspectives. Deontological approaches illuminate the duties and professional obligations that communicators owe to audiences, while consequentialist perspectives highlight the broader social impacts and unintended harm that AI-enabled communication may produce. As scholars have argued in analyses of complex ethical failures, including McDonell’s discussion of the BP oil spill, multifaceted ethical problems are best examined through multiple ethical lenses rather than a single framework. Nevertheless, virtue ethics provides a foundational orientation by insisting that ethical communication ultimately begins with the communicator’s character.

Regardless of how advanced AI systems become, responsibility for their ethical use remains with the human beings who exercise judgment over their deployment. Indeed, Carradini (2024; 2025) emphasizes the necessity for technical communicators to document the historical moment, changes, and future directions of AI study and practice in TPC. Carradini emphasizes the importance of “marking this moment” (2024, p.194) and suggests that “we should think big when we think about AI – whether we are for, against, or neutral on the topic” (2025, p.7). At this moment, AI development is changing rapidly, creating new questions, fears, and opportunities. This is a key opportunity to reflect on responsible communication and the communicator’s ethical stance.