R U Cooked or R U Cooking?: Revisiting Platonic Binaries in a Neoliberal Age
by Loren James Smith | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Introduction
My son is an avid gamer, and like many kids his age, he often narrates his gameplay. His commentary is jargon filled: playing with newbs, one-shotting opponents, unlocking new skins, or backstabbing another player. What strikes me as almost Shakespearean, however, is his tendency to declare that he is either “cooked” or “cooking.” There is rarely any language of moderation. He is either succeeding spectacularly or failing completely. There is no discourse for simply getting by or performing adequately because, in the virtual worlds he inhabits, there is only victory or defeat, life or death. There is no in-between.
Of course, this kind of binary rhetoric is hardly unique to gaming. Throughout our lives, we are confronted with choices and situations that seem to reduce the world to opposing categories: good or bad, success or failure, us or them, etc. When the call for the 25th anniversary issue of Xchanges invited authors to revisit an article from the journal’s archives, I was immediately drawn to the idea of looking at the way people had written about rhetoric.
There was a lot to choose from. I knew, for example, that there would be a lot to say about Jason Tham’s 2016 article “Rhetorical Web Design: Thinking Critically about Ready-Made Web Templates and the Problem of Ease” which argues that ready-made templates and code databases can hinder learning, voice, and creativity when it comes to web design. My first conclusion after reading Tham’s article was that someone, somewhere working with AI coding agents and the new trend of “vibe coding” must have something to add to this conversation, but without any real coding / web design experience, I felt that I didn’t have the technical knowledge to weigh in. I felt very similarly about McDonell’s “The Ethics of Visual Rhetoric & Photo Manipulation” which is remarkably timely in this age of deepfakes and hyperrealism.
I also considered two articles close to my childhood: Martin’s 2020 article, “The Shrine of Chino Mine: Extraction Rhetoric and Public Memory in Southern New Mexico” and Feng’s 2021 article, “Bad Sex vs. No Sex: The Rhetoric of Heteronormative Temporality in Utah’s Abstinence-Based Education.” Having grown up in Utah next to a Kennecott Copper Mine, I loved the way these articles analyzed rhetoric I had lived with as a kid. While these articles deal with two very different communities, I think that their underlying messages share some commonalities: one being that omission (Feng’s article) or destruction (Martin’s article) of rhetorical texts marginalizes people. Even though I chose a different article to revisit, I highly recommend you read these articles if you have the time because they are excellent looks into how rhetoric affects the communities we live in.
The article I ultimately chose to revisit is Ross’s 2009 article “Pedagogy Shaped by Ideology: Beneath or Beyond Plato” which appeared in issue 6.1. Ross was a plucky undergrad finishing up at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs when she published this article. I’d say that’s pretty impressive considering that when I was a senior at Utah State, my attention was solely devoted to passing the final general education credits I had put off the last 5 years.
What really strikes me about Ross’s article 17 years after Xchanges published it is just how damn smart it is. I’ve been teaching composition for 12 years now, and I’d like to think that I have a pretty good sense of what undergraduate writing is, but I would never have guessed this article was written by an undergraduate student if Xchanges hadn’t of included a bio of Ross at the end. Her achievement here is incredible, a wonderful benchmark for anyone studying writing in their undergraduate careers and part of the incredible showcase Xchanges has achieved in the last 25 years as the premier champions of student research. With that spirit in mind, I have endeavored to showcase Xchanges authors as much as possible in this article, which I hope will show just how amazing they, and by extension, we are.
