|

R U Cooked or R U Cooking?: Revisiting Platonic Binaries in a Neoliberal Age

by Loren James Smith | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Making $$$$$ The Plato Way

Before we begin, I’d like to define what I mean by neoliberal. Neoliberalism according to Gallagher is “…a form of cultural politics and a set of economic principles, policies, and practices devoted to handing over as much of social life as possible to private interests.” (Being There: (Re)Making the Assessment Scene, 453). In short, neoliberalism seeks to privatize public services (such as public universities) and the rights and authority of those who work in the public sector.

Concrete examples of neoliberalism are copious, but rather than attempting to catalogue them all, I would instead like to focus on one that is particularly important to college writing: the assessment scene. I do so for two reasons. First, assessment is one of the primary ways the world translates educational value into measurable outcomes, making it an ideal site for examining neoliberal assumptions about productivity, accountability, and the cost of education. Second, assessment is something that every writing instructor and every student encounters. Whether through grades, rubrics, standardized outcomes, or portfolio evaluations, assessment shapes not only how writing is judged but also how it is taught, produced, and understood.

If neoliberalism has fundamentally altered higher education, then its influence should be especially visible in the ways we evaluate students. Broad examples in the United States are government acts and reports like No Child Left Behind (NCLB) (2002), Common, Core, Standards (2010), and Every Student Succeeds Act (2015). These acts and reports led to outsourced, standardized testing in the United States for most K-12 students and are certainly companions to acts such as The Spellings Report (2006), and Academically Adrift (2011) which have called for collegial reform and greater accountability for college and universities. Neoliberalism’s interest in standardized testing is complicated, and I turn to Gallagher again, whom I quote at length, to explain:

“Assessment, particularly standardized testing, is useful to the neoliberal agenda for several reasons: it provides fodder for continuous, manufactured education crises; it functions as a surveillance apparatus; it promotes self-regulation within the system; it serves as a lever for score keeping and competition; it (supposedly) requires technical knowledge that only private vendors can provide; it promotes standardization and therefore (purportedly) efficiency. At the K-12 level, neoliberal reform has outsourced assessment to the testing and test prep industry, which enjoys an unregulated marketplace and government subsidization through the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) law. Curriculum is largely packaged by textbook companies, instruction is often scripted by off-the-shelf programs, and “supplemental instruction” is increasingly provided by private vendors. Commercial providers supply an array of “supplemental services”—sometimes the full range of operations—to “failing” schools and districts.” (Being There: (Re)Making the Assessment Scene, 454).

We don’t have time to dive deeply into every one of Gallagher’s claims here but lets look at one: education crises. A literacy education crisis is the belief that students can’t read/write as well as they should. While not all literacy crises are manufactured through assessment, many are; even though privatized, mass testing of literacy is deeply flawed, and most often does not reflect the critical thinking skills and outcomes that all good writing courses endeavor to teach. Perelman can explain for us why that is:

“With mass market tests, such as the ones I have been discussing, that are given to hundreds of thousands a students per year, the cost of grading essays constitutes a substantial part of the test’s overall cost. Test providers, then, whether they are for-profit companies or large non-profit entities such as the Educational Testing Service, seek essay prompts that will minimize the time needed by a reader to score the essay while simultaneously ensuring inter-reader reliability that can be used as a self-referential indicator of validity. Evaluating different paraphrases of a source, for example, is much more difficult and time consuming, and has more potential for disagreement than the mechanical counting of quotations. Indeed, in general, quantitative features, such as the frequency of infrequently used words like plethora, can be graded much more quickly and reliably by human readers than qualitative features, such as creativity in accurately rephrasing an idea.” (138).

The “mechanical counting of quotations” and “the frequency of infrequently used words like plethora” Perelman lists here as being optimal ways of scoring mass tests is reminiscent of Ross’s idea that platonic rhetoric prefers “grammatical correctness, vocabulary, and the presence of analysis over the development of thought and the quality of content.” The testing industry prefers the binary of Platonic rhetoric because it is easily quantifiable, and thus easily assessed which in turn increases profitability, control, etc.

Furthermore, Perelman’s identification of practices that are more difficult to assess, and thus more time consuming and not as profitable, such as the “creativity in accurately rephrasing an idea” are likely impossible for LLMs and other assessment machines- Can AI accurately judge something as creative if itself is not creative? An LLM can search a database and tell you (with varying degrees of accuracy) that something has never been written about, but is scarcity the only measure of creativity?

There are many assessment practices that reject binary / platonic rhetoric. Ross mentions one when they write that, “An alternative for instructors who want to resist the binary framework that is rooted in the Platonic tradition is assessing student writing by examining the progress of individual writers’ work over the span of multiple drafts.” This is simplistic but remember that Ross had likely never taught a college level course before at this time in their career. So, let’s fill in the gaps.

When it comes to in-class assessment practices, there are actually a lot of methods we can choose from. There is, for example, mastery grading (students demonstrate full understanding of a skill before earning credit), competency-based grading (grades are based on what students can do, rather than the time spent on assignments), and contract grading, which I will dive into more deeply because contract grading has received more attention in writing classrooms than the aforementioned strategies.

Contract grading is an assessment practice where the instructor and students agree in advance on a set of specific assignments and expectations, and a student’s final grade is determined by whether they fulfill the terms of that contract. Contract grading is a bit of a broad term that covers a wide range of assessment practices that may still include some traditional assessment practices. Labor-based grading is one form of contract grading. In this approach, students earn grades based on the amount, consistency, and completion of their work, such as drafts, revisions, and participation, rather than the instructor’s judgment of the final product’s quality. Because labor-based grading depends on the measure of labor rather than standards or correctness, it has the possibility to disrupt language supremacy- a primary reason it’s used in writing classrooms. Inoue covers this extensively in his open-source book, Labor-Based Grading Contracts: Building Equity and Inclusion in the Compassionate Writing Classroom.

In that book, Inoue doesn’t mince words about the binary of good/bad writing. Though he doesn’t discuss it in the way Ross does, he writes, “standards for good writing are deeply informed by a white racial habitus, which makes grading by such standards white supremacist. I am not saying that you (the teacher) are a bad person, but grading by a standard does make your grading methods and your grading ecology in your classroom racist, and white supremacist.” (9).

While labor-based contract grading enjoys a healthy interest and acceptable use at many institutions, contract / labor-based grading is not a universally accepted practice. Inoue gamely endeavors to answer critics question in chapter 6 of the book I mentioned above, but graduate students still face pressure to use more traditional systems. For example, in “Brooke’s narrative” of D’Orazio, Monthe, Bolin, and Evans, “The TPC Contact Zone: Preparing Graduate Student Instructors for Students’ Writing Realities” Bolin writes: “However, after spending two semesters using engagement-based contract grades, I was told that this grading scheme was a threat to the standardization required by other schools within the college and was asked to no longer use contract grading when teaching these courses. I felt incredibly frustrated, not least by the fact that I had been teaching this way for a year before anybody noticed, and I was provided no additional assistance for how to shift my syllabus for future teaching semesters.”

Ryan, in “Teaching Boldly, Teaching Queerly: Embracing Radical (Un)Growth and Possibilities as a Graduate Instructor in First-Year Writing” had similar experiences, “This decision [to use an alternative grading contract], to my surprise, received some significant pushback. This pushback came not from my students (nor have I ever since received negative feedback about my grading method from students: in fact, many have noted it as a highlight of their experience) but from other voices, one of which escalated to a major conflict with someone in a position of authority in my first semester of teaching. I was in a position of deference to this voice, and the situation was severe enough I began having panic attacks and a multitude of bureaucratic consequences. This was a further moment of loss of innocence… I cared so deeply about my teaching, and my students’ experiences, that to see this decision fall under such severe scrutiny was distressing in multiple ways.”

If Inoue is correct and traditional assessment practices reinforce binary standards of good/bad writing and are reflective of white mainstream English, and thus language homogenization, white supremacy, etc., it is perhaps pertinent to also remind readers that, as Hamilton pointed out earlier, Standard Academic English was deeply influenced by those privileged enough to enjoy academic life (white men) as it historically developed. Consequently, Bolin and Ryan are fighting an academic infrastructure built on platonic binaries Ross has pointed out that empower white mainstream English and thus assessment practices of good / bad writing.

Furthermore, the institutional barriers they encountered are deeply rooted in neoliberal, traditional, institutional structure and broader national legislation far beyond their immediate classrooms. For example, outcomes for first year writing are assessment elements monitored and influenced both by university administration and state legislature because these outcomes play important roles in general education credit transfer, and institutional accreditation which, in turn, is tied to institutional funding among other things. When graduate students disrupt this process by utilizing alternate grading practices, some administrators may think that they are inadvertently endangering the delicate processes mentioned above. Most of this structure is likely ambient to the graduate students mentioned, and perhaps, to the authoritative voices that put a stop to their labor-based assessment practices.

I write this not to discourage graduate students from using labor based grading or alternate grading practices. Though I don’t believe that labor-based grading is perfect, I do believe labor-based grading can disrupt the good / bad writing binary, and language homogenization. I simply mean to say that administration cannot be solely blamed for problems that exist at a cultural level. It’s more lucrative to standardize white mainstream English than a multitude of lingual identities because it’s easier to assess. This neoliberal push isn’t coming from one source, but rather a society. Consequently, reform must come from society itself, and the writing community has long been a champion of that reform.