|

R U Cooked or R U Cooking?: Revisiting Platonic Binaries in a Neoliberal Age

by Loren James Smith | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Broad Outcomes for Broad Paths

Ross argues that modern composition theories like process pedagogy and social epistemic rhetoric challenged the platonic model of writing pedagogy by treating writing as a dynamic, evolving process that creates meaning rather than simply reflecting fixed truth. In other words, a framework that values context, multiple truths, and flexibility would allow writing to function as a tool for discovery, creativity, and knowledge-making. To some degree, labor-based grading is attempting this feat, but as I began this article discussing platonic rhetoric, I would like to end it by discussing modern theories of rhetoric that reveal neoliberal agenda and the platonic binaries that support it.

It likely goes without saying that there isn’t some secret cabal of Platonic cultists dead set on enforcing white mainstream English in the classroom. No one (or at least very few people) sit down with Phaedrus in their arms when they start building their writing courses for the coming semester. The influence of Plato and binary rhetoric is really more of a ghost in the system which has been built brick by brick on the backs of 2500 years of western pedagogy that we’re not always conscious of.

This is an important way of looking back at Ross’s assertion that many writing pedagogies are influenced by binary / platonic rhetoric. The implicit rhetoric of our lives, historically dictating to us what is good / bad writing is a difficult anchor to drop. However, that’s not to say that writing teachers haven’t tried. Ross covered process theory and social epistemic rhetoric, but what are some more specific examples of pedagogies that avoid binary rhetorics of good / bad?

Well, in Xchanges, there are a lot of ways people are doing this; Lonelodge and Rieger in, “Student Perceptions of Writing Instruction: Twitter as a Tool for Pedagogical Growth” offer a pedagogical path based on student tweets and feedback on how to develop an empathetic pedagogy that fits with a rhetoric of creativity and exploration. Jennings, in “Chat(GPT)-ing about the Affordances Generative AI Tools Offer for ADHD Writers” explains how the writing process is different for everyone, especially neurodivergent writers, and how new tools like ChatGPT can positively impact those processes reflecting Ross’s multiple truth epistemologies. Tucker, Hawkins, Mansure, and Minnillo in their article “Supporting Students’ Own Languages in the Writing Classroom: Adaptable Writing Assignments for Enacting Linguistic Justice in Local Contexts” shared assignments that let students use their full linguistic repertoires and enact linguistic justice in ways that challenges the binary of the Platonic rhetoric Ross describes.

An important development since Ross wrote her article in 2009 is the development of ambient rhetoric by Thomas Rickert and the publication of his 2013 book, “Ambient Rhetoric: The Attunement of Rhetorical Being.” Among other things, ambient rhetoric argues that much of the rhetoric that influences who we are (and thus what we teach and how we teach it is) is ambient, unseen or undetected. This theory asserts that rhetoric can be found everywhere; not just in human beings, but in nonhuman rhetors such as machines (algorithms, content moderation, AI, etc.), animals and the natural world. In this view, the digital spaces we inhabit, the animals we interact with, and the environments we live in persuade us to feel, think, and act in unique ways.

Viewing all things as rhetorical disrupts platonic binaries by encouraging people to analyze rhetoric beyond the institutional structures they live in. It can connect human beings, and their actions, to unseen histories and the natural world, in complex, dynamic ways. It also has the potential to disrupt the dominance of western rhetoric as it asks us to see rhetoric as a universal trait, rather than a Grecian invention.

Teaching ambient rhetoric, however, can be a difficult task because there is little framework for it in the classroom. It’s difficult to conceptualize and is a difficult form of analysis, particularly for students. How, for example, do you apply traditional rhetorical concepts like ethos, pathos, logos, kairos, to an algorithm when it does not feel, think, or reason and is largely invisible?

Loe offers an example of applying ambient rhetoric in research. In “What it is exactly that circulates”: Affective value, re/production, and rhetorical exchange” she rhetorically analyzed the communications of adults in a fantasy football league through an ambient lens. Among her complex findings, which unravel neoliberal systems at work in the fantasy league and the lives of her participants, she writes “Just because some rhetorical activity may fade into the background of daily life, becoming ambient behavior to us, doesn’t mean it isn’t extraordinarily useful to those in power” (Loe, 13).

Loe’s work demonstrates the value of ambient rhetoric because it reveals how rhetorical forces operate through their invisibility (much in the same way it operated for Bolin and Ryan). The rhetorical technology the fantasy league used to communicate was exploited through data harvesting that was ultimately monetized in various ways, including boosting the engagement and ad revenue of the app itself. This, in turn, subtly altered the way the fantasy league communicated. Reducing human interaction to as fine a point as possible in order to monetize it is certainly reflective of platonic rhetoric and neoliberalism. Thus, Loe’s scholarship therefore offers scholars a framework for identifying neoliberal agenda and rhetorical activity that exists beyond traditional communicative technologies and for recognizing how seemingly neutral systems can participate in larger structures of power.

Another example would be Goodwin, Miller and Chaput’s, “Accountable to whom? The rhetorical circulation of neoliberal discourse and its ambient effects on higher education.” In their article, they conclude that the faculty in the CSU and SUNY systems lost local authority and power over assessment, standardization, and the purpose of education in their classrooms to big data assessment and neoliberal agendas because they failed to understand the ambient environment of educational reform present in their states.

This analysis is particularly useful because it demonstrates how assessment technologies can exert rhetorical influence without operating as direct, traditional rhetorical agents. The compounded rhetorical effect of years of legislation, even though they are flawed, can result in a rhetorical environment which fosters neoliberal practices, or in this instance, the wresting of authority from academic experts. Like Loe’s analysis of fantasy football, Goodwin, Miller, and Chaput show how rhetorical forces can fade into the background while still producing powerful effects. Their proposed response (community action) also recognizes that resisting these forces requires collective awareness of the ambient environment in which they exist and participation within the larger world because oftentimes, the rhetorical environments which platonic rhetoric produces are simply too large to be solved by one single person or entity.

I’d like to offer two more quick examples, one pedagogical and one cultural. Rule asked her students to draw and analyze the material environments of the rooms in which they write, showing how the material objects within them are interconnected with students’ writing practices. Rule writes, “I see writing’s rooms and these multimodal methods as especially useful for writers in our classrooms. And I raise them to argue for something ultimately quite simple: it is good for writers to see writing happen in its infinite variety, modes, and locations.” (428).

By asking students to attend to the spaces and material environments that surround their writing, Rule helps them recognize rhetorical influences that often disappear into the background of everyday composing. This approach is particularly relevant for teaching students about digital and algorithmic environments. Just as a desk, computer, notebook, or physical workspace shapes how writers compose, digital infrastructures such as platforms, interfaces, algorithms, and artificial intelligence systems also participate in shaping writing practices. In doing so, students move beyond understanding rhetoric as something produced only through intentional human communication and toward a more expansive understanding of rhetoric as something that emerges through interactions among humans, materials, and environments. While Rule doesn’t discuss neoliberalism, this approach is multitudinal, rather than binary, in the sense that it invites students to analyze rhetorical influences that are beyond human beings.

Grant, like the others I’ve mentioned, also takes a unique approach by utilizing ambient and material rhetoric to rhetorically analyze the chanupa, a sacred ceremonial pipe of the Lakota and other sovereign nations. In so doing he concludes that, “Looking at the chanupa as a rhetorical object extends the notion of indigenous rhetoric and rhetorical sovereignty to the nonhuman, complexly material, and ontological. The chanupa, as the Lakota understand it, is a key instrument of maintaining relations and responsibilities so that the Lakota may exist. It is an object of real consequence in maintaining, modulating and constellating their individual and collective being. It is writing wakan, both powerful and mysterious.” (84).

Grant’s analysis demonstrates the broader value of ambient and material rhetoric: these approaches allow scholars to recognize rhetorical activity as ontological and existing outside dominant Western frameworks of communication and persuasion. In doing so, they create opportunities to examine rhetorical environments that are often overlooked or dismissed because they do not fit traditional definitions of rhetoric.