|

R U Cooked or R U Cooking?: Revisiting Platonic Binaries in a Neoliberal Age

by Loren James Smith | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

“Goodnight, Pink Birthday Star Band-Aid Puppy”

As I close out this paper, I’d like to share with you one more thing my kids say that seems pertinent to this article. My daughter, who is three, has a lengthy, routine heavy bedtime which involves brushing teeth, using the potty, reading some books, and singing some songs. At the end of all this, when it’s time say goodnight, my wife will ask her what she wants to be called. For my daughter, who is 3 years old, that combination of things is an amalgamation of all the things that she seems to love best in the world. A multitudinal expression of her identity and the things she sees in her rhetorical environment. The current iteration of this is Pink Birthday Star Band-Aid Puppy. That, to me, is a perfect explanation of the many possibilities ambient rhetoric can afford us.

Ross concludes her essay by writing that “Writers, teachers, and rhetoricians who want to inhabit an environment where writing is meaningful and genuine have a choice. They can continue to work inside a Platonic framework which generates abundant problems, or they can intentionally leave Plato, his philosophies, his pedagogy, and his epistemologies behind by choosing to ground the teaching of writing in rhetoric instead of philosophy.”

As Xchanges celebrates its twenty-fifth anniversary, it is worth reflecting on how rhetorical conversations like this have continued to evolve. Xchanges, like all scholarly environments, are continuously transforming through the complex relationship among authors, readers, ideas, and disciplinary communities. Ambient rhetoric offers one possible framework for understanding these complex environments and the ways meaning emerges through them.

Although a pedagogical framework for ambient rhetoric is still being developed, the scholars discussed above provide important lessons for how writing teachers can help students move beyond binary understandings of rhetoric and toward a more relational understanding of how meaning is created. In the classroom, this means creating opportunities for students to recognize the infinite rhetorical environments that surround them and the often-invisible forces that influence their lives. Specifically, educators can:

  • Ask students to consider how the communication platforms they use direct, affect, and influence their personalities, identities, and broader environments.
  • Ask students to consider how their own authority and agency are shaped by the institutions and environments they inhabit, while also exploring how they might reclaim rhetorical power within those systems.
  • Ask students to consider the material spaces they exist within and how those spaces shape, transform, and participate in the development of their identities.
  • Ask students to consider how the histories of their homes, places, communities, and families function rhetorically to define and influence who they become.

By crafting assignments that encourage students to examine these relationships, writing teachers can help students move beyond binaries and recognize the larger rhetorical environments in which they participate. Such approaches allow students to identify the neoliberal agendas embedded within many of the systems they encounter while also recognizing their own ability to respond, reshape, and participate within those environments.