Teaching in the Contact Zone: The Lived Experience of an International Graduate Instructor
by Ekomabasi Obot Udoete | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
What This Means for the Contact Zone
Contact zone pedagogy, as articulated in the literature, consistently positions instructors as central, stable figures responsible for structuring, guiding, and sustaining the classroom as a productive site of negotiation. Pratt (1991) urges educators to “look for the pedagogical arts of the contact zone” (p. 40), a call that has been taken up by scholars who emphasize the need for deliberate, instructor-led intervention in shaping these spaces. In response, Horton’s (2021) literature advocates for a “revolution via new pedagogical approaches” that prioritize creating “safe spaces for learners to unpack linguistic and cultural conceptions” and engage in “meaningful interactions with new ideas” (p. 3). Within this framework, instructors are not passive participants but active designers of the contact zone, tasked with making it accessible and navigable for students. This role is further reinforced through the metaphor of the instructor as a “travel agent or tour guide,” one who “makes the contact zone tangible for students and help[s] them navigate the different learning experiences they encounter within it” (p. 7). Such a framing assumes that all instructors possess the linguistic competence necessary to guide students through unfamiliar rhetorical and linguistic terrain.
Horton (2021) further underscores that instructors must actively cultivate environments that enable students to engage productively with difference. Students are expected to “socialize within their translingual environment” and develop reflexive awareness through “turning back to discover, examine and critique one’s claims and assumptions” (p. 3)
However, this process is contingent upon the instructor’s ability to construct a classroom environment that supports such exploration. As emphasized, “instructors must create an environment that is conducive to discovery through error-making,” ensuring that students feel comfortable engaging with uncertainty and difference (p. 3). This responsibility extends to instructors’ own communicative practices, as they must remain “aware of how they talk about writing” and model the kind of reflective, equitable engagement they expect from students (p. 4). Without such intentional facilitation, the contact zone risks becoming “oppressive,” as students may misinterpret or disengage from the complex dynamics of identity and power at play. Thus, instructors are positioned as essential to ensuring that the contact zone functions as a productive, rather than harmful space (p. 7).
At the same time, Horton (2021), places significant emphasis on the instructor’s ethical and ideological role within the contact zone. Teachers are expected to “exemplify equitable, decolonizing practices” (p. 7) and foster “an amicable relationship-based environment” that supports students’ identity negotiation and literacy development. They must also engage in reflexive inquiry, continually examining their own positionality while co-constructing knowledge with students in ways that “equitably distribute power across stakeholders” (p. 7). Even the caution against exotifying the cultures explored within the contact zone reinforces the expectation that instructors possess the critical awareness necessary to navigate complex cultural dynamics responsibly. Taken together, these expectations construct a particular image of the instructor within contact zone theory: one who is linguistically proficient, culturally competent, reflexive, and capable of managing the complexities of difference, able to “closely attend to what our students say and write” and respond to the “strange, sometimes threatening, multivocal texts” produced within the contact zone (Horton, 2021).
However, attending to the multilingual international graduate instructor within this framework reveals a critical limitation in these assumptions. While the literature positions instructors as those who guide students through linguistic and cultural difference, it does not fully account for situations in which the instructor’s own linguistic identity becomes a source of instability within the classroom. For multilingual instructors whose accents or speech patterns fall outside dominant norms, the ability to function as a “tour guide” or facilitator cannot be taken for granted. Instead of occupying a position of uncontested authority, these instructors may find themselves simultaneously guiding and being evaluated, teaching and being misunderstood, facilitating and being positioned as a problem within the very space they are expected to manage.
The autoethnographic experience presented in this study illustrates this tension clearly. Despite receiving an Advanced High rating on the OPIc exam and being institutionally recognized as proficient, my authority was undermined when students complained, revealing that linguistic legitimacy was determined not by institutional validation but by student perception.
Similarly, moments in which students responded with “huh?” or requested repetition reflect what Pratt describes as “miscomprehension” and “incomprehension,” not as isolated breakdowns in communication but as conditions shaped by linguistic expectation and power. These interactions positioned me not as a stable facilitator of the contact zone, but as a participant within it, whose authority was subject to ongoing negotiation.
My experience further extends this dynamic, demonstrating how authority can be destabilized through subtle, ambiguous interactions, students smiling, wearing earbuds, or repeatedly asking for clarification. These moments produced a heightened reflexivity in teaching practice, where instruction became not only about delivering content but also about monitoring how one’s speech was being received in real time. In this sense, authority was not inherent to the instructor’s role but co-constructed through ongoing interaction.
When these experiences are read alongside contact zone pedagogy, a significant shift emerges in how the contact zone must be understood. The assumption that instructors can function as “tour guides” who seamlessly facilitate linguistic and cultural negotiation overlooks the reality that they may simultaneously be navigating their own legitimacy within the same space. Rather than occupying a position outside the contact zone, multilingual instructors are embedded within it, experiencing the same instability, negotiation, and asymmetrical power relations that the theory has traditionally attributed to students. This is further illustrated in contrasting classroom contexts: in linguistically diverse classrooms, my authority was less contested, while in predominantly monolingual classrooms, my accent became hypervisible and destabilizing, despite no change in my teaching practice. These moments demonstrate that authority is not fixed but relational, shaped by student expectations and linguistic ideologies.
Thus, what changes in the contact zone is not simply who participates, but how authority, power, and legitimacy are distributed and experienced. The contact zone can no longer be understood as a space where instructors guide students from a position of stability; instead, it must be reconceptualized as a shared, dynamic environment in which both instructors and students engage in the negotiation of meaning, identity, and authority. This reframing extends the past two and a half decades of student-centered contact zone scholarship by revealing that the very conditions, miscomprehension, instability, and asymmetrical power, that scholars have used to describe student experience also shape the experiences of international graduate instructors. Recognizing this not only expands the theoretical scope of the contact zone but also exposes the need to reconsider how linguistic authority is constructed, perceived, and contested within writing classrooms.
This is not to suggest that linguistic identity is the only way instructor authority is contested. Monolingual instructors may also face challenges to their legitimacy because of race, gender, age, disability, or other aspects of their identity. The contact zone, understood as a space where authority is negotiated through social interaction, can account for these different forms of contestation. Rather than arguing that linguistic identity is uniquely destabilizing, this study focuses on one dimension of instructor authority, accent and linguistic identity, to show how it is negotiated within the contact zone. Future research might examine how linguistic identity intersects with other social identities to shape perceptions of instructor legitimacy across different classroom contexts.
Although Horton (2021) serves as a key example throughout this article, the assumption that instructors occupy stable positions of authority extends beyond a single source. Scholarship on classroom facilitation more broadly often portrays instructors as responsible for creating inclusive, productive learning environments, implicitly treating their authority as stable and unquestioned. At the same time, research on non-native English-speaking teachers (NNESTs) and international teaching assistants (ITAs) (Moussu & Llurda, 2008; Ramjattan, 2020, 2022) has begun to document the vulnerabilities multilingual instructors experience, particularly those related to accent, legitimacy, and classroom authority. However, this work has largely developed outside the framework of contact zone theory. Building on these studies, this article brings multilingual instructor experiences into conversation with contact zone theory to argue that instructors, like students, are participants in the negotiation of meaning, power, and authority.
Central to this reframing is the idea of relationality: authority, legitimacy, and meaning in the classroom are not fixed qualities that instructors possess but are produced through interactions between instructors and students. While contact zone scholarship has largely explored these negotiations from the perspective of students, this study argues that they also shape the instructor’s experience. My authority did not exist independently of classroom interactions; rather, it was continually constructed through everyday exchanges, including requests for repetition, laughter, eye contact, and other responses to my speech. Viewed this way, relationality becomes more than a description of classroom dynamics. It provides a way of understanding instructor authority as something negotiated in practice rather than guaranteed by institutional credentials such as oral proficiency scores, teaching certifications, or academic degrees.
