|

Teaching in the Contact Zone: The Lived Experience of an International Graduate Instructor

by Ekomabasi Obot Udoete | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Understanding the Contact Zone

Mary Louise Pratt (1991) introduced the concept of the contact zone to explain how people from different cultural and linguistic backgrounds interact, negotiate meaning, and navigate unequal power relations. In these spaces, interaction is shaped by differences in language, culture, and social position. Pratt also notes that writing in the contact zone involves significant risks, including “miscomprehension, incomprehension, dead letters, unread masterpieces, [and] absolute heterogeneity of meaning” (p. 37). These perils highlight the instability of communication in contact zones. Miscomprehension and incomprehension refer to moments when individuals misunderstand or fail to understand one another. Dead letters and unread masterpieces describe ideas or contributions that go unrecognized or unacknowledged by others. Finally, what Pratt (1991) calls “absolute heterogeneity of meaning” reflects how individuals may interpret the same language or message in fundamentally different ways (p. 37). Together, these conditions illustrate how communication in contact zones is shaped by unequal power relations and differing linguistic and cultural frameworks, making meaning contingent, negotiated, and often unstable.

Other scholars have described contact zones as multifaceted spaces shaped by interaction, power, and negotiation across both material and symbolic dimensions. Mullen (2005) conceptualizes contact zones as “a cluster of symbolic and material spaces,” drawing attention to the fact that they exist not only in physical locations such as classrooms but also within symbolic domains like language, identity, and discourse (p. 22). Similarly, Singh and Doherty (2004) define contact zones as “spatial, temporal locations,” emphasizing that these spaces are situated within specific contexts and moments rather than existing as abstract or static constructs (p. 12). Expanding on this, Negash (2009) characterizes contact zones as “intensely contested political and cultural space[s]” and as “physical and imagined terrains of concurrent colonial appropriation and negation,” highlighting how power and resistance operate simultaneously within these environments (pp. 76, 79). Other scholars further underscore the instability and unevenness of contact zones, describing them as “uneven terrain” (Yeoh & Willis, 2005, p. 282) that can be “transformative, generative, and disruptive” (West, 1996, p. 147), as well as “challenging” and “destabilizing” (Chidester, 2008, p. 64).

These descriptions collectively point to the inherently dynamic and unpredictable nature of contact zones, where interactions do not follow fixed or stable patterns. Pratt’s (1991) observation that the contact zone is a space where “no one [is] excluded, and no one [is] safe” (pp. 38–39) suggests that negotiation and contestation extend to everyone within it, including instructors whose authority is shaped by linguistic difference. Taken together, these perspectives position the contact zone as a complex and evolving environment in which meaning, authority, and identity are not predetermined but are continuously produced and reshaped through interaction.

Within educational contexts, Cynthia Fields (2015), explains that the concept of the contact zone has been widely applied across various academic spaces and practices. Fields notes that scholars have used the contact zone to examine “the academy itself” (Canagarajah, 1997), research relationships (Manathunga, 2009), English studies as a discipline (Bizzell 1994), and English as a second language contexts (Singh & Doherty 2004), as well as the experiences of international students in the “global university” (Fields, 2015, p. 38). She further observes that contact zones have been used to understand academic conferences, writing centers, and peer response groups, highlighting the classroom and related academic spaces as sites of interaction shaped by linguistic and cultural difference (Fields, 2015, p. 38). According to Fields, invoking the English classroom as a contact zone has also served as “a way of organizing literary study” (Bizzell 1994) and as “a rationale for integrating English studies multiculturally”, particularly through the inclusion of diverse literatures and perspectives (p. 39). Fields also draws on Miller’s argument that the “central activity” of the classroom as contact zone is “investigating the range of literate practices available to those within asymmetrical power relationships” (Miller 1994, p. 399 as cited in Fields, 2015), emphasizing how classrooms function as spaces where language, literacy, and authority are negotiated (p. 38). Through this synthesis, Fields (2015) highlights how contact zone theory has shaped how scholars understand educational spaces as sites of linguistic, cultural, and ideological interaction.

Pratt (1991) conceptualizes the contact zone classroom as a space organized around interaction among participants navigating cultural, linguistic, and hierarchical differences. She suggests that pedagogy in such settings may involve practices such as “exercises in storytelling” and opportunities for participants to engage with “the ideas, interests, histories, and attitudes of others,” alongside “experiments in transculturation and collaborative work” and the use of critique, parody, and comparison (p. 33). These approaches foreground engagement across differences and invite participants to encounter perspectives beyond their own. 1also emphasizes “the redemption of the oral” and encourages “ways for people to engage with suppressed aspects of history,” highlighting the value of diverse modes of expression and historically marginalized voices (p. 33). Collectively, these practices frame the classroom as a space where meaning emerges through interaction among individuals shaped by different linguistic, cultural, and historical contexts.

Importantly, Pratt (1991) repeatedly refers to “people” rather than limiting her description to students alone. For example, she describes contact zone pedagogy as involving “ways for people to engage with suppressed aspects of history” and “ground rules for communication across lines of difference and hierarchy that go beyond politeness but maintain mutual respect” (p. 33). Her use of the broader term “people” emphasizes that the contact zone includes all participants within the classroom and that communication occurs across differences in power, identity, and authority. By framing the contact zone as a space where “people” engage in storytelling, critique, collaboration, and cultural mediation, Pratt (1991) highlights the relational nature of the classroom, where meaning, authority, and legitimacy are shaped through interaction rather than fixed roles. This emphasis on interaction across difference reinforces that the contact zone is defined by ongoing negotiation among participants within asymmetrical relations of power.

However, the writing studies scholarship often assumes that instructors occupy stable positions of linguistic authority within the classroom. As Matsuda and Silva (2011) argue, “even though various iterations of writing classrooms like ‘mainstream,’ ‘ESL,’ or ‘cross-cultural’ exist, a reality of increased globalization is that students of all kinds of cultural and linguistic backgrounds enter all types of writing classrooms” (p. 253). They further emphasize that writing teachers must adopt pedagogical strategies that support students at different stages of linguistic development. (Matsuda & Silva, 2011, as cited in Horton, 2021, p. 2). This framing positions the instructor as a linguistically secure authority whose role is to guide students through linguistic and cultural differences.

Scholarship on multilingual writing classrooms places significant responsibility on instructors to accommodate linguistic diversity, arguing that it is critical for teachers to integrate pedagogical strategies that support students and meet them where they are (McCook, 2016; Bizzell, 1997, as cited in Horton, 2021, p. 2). This expectation is reinforced through contact zone pedagogy, which positions instructors as active agents responsible for shaping and managing these spaces. As Horton notes through McCook, writing classrooms are sites where instructors take a “proactive approach” to implementing contact zone-informed practices, helping students engage with “linguistic and rhetorical dynamics” and providing opportunities for experimentation (McCook, 2016 as cited in Horton, 2021, p. 2). Within this framework, instructors are expected to carefully construct “contact zones that are enabling ones, in which all voices are heard” (Gottschalk 2002, as cited in Horton, 2021, p. 3), while also facilitating “safe” and “authentic” spaces that promote “restorative, liberatory literacies” (Pritchard, 2017, Hooks, 1994, as cited in Horton, 2021, p. 3).

Taken together, these perspectives construct the instructor as linguistically competent, stable, and capable of managing difference within the classroom. In other words, they assume that the instructor possesses the linguistic authority necessary to lead the contact zone, mediate misunderstanding, and ensure that all voices are recognized and respected. Horton’s (2021) framing of instructors as facilitators of the contact zone further reinforces this assumption, positioning them as figures who can confidently navigate linguistic and cultural difference on behalf of their students.

Additionally, Cynthia Fields (2015) explains that the contact zone has often been associated with developing students’ reflection and critical awareness (p. 39). Through this framework, Fields demonstrates how contact zone theory has been used to understand writing classrooms as spaces where students critically engage with language, authority, and meaning, (p. 39). As Fields demonstrates, contact zone theory has been widely used in composition studies to examine how students develop critical consciousness by reflecting on their linguistic practices and confronting the unequal power relations that shape academic discourse. Within this framework, the classroom is understood as a space where students encounter “colliding voices” and learn to recognize how their reading, writing, and interpretive choices are shaped by broader discursive structures (p. 39).

However, this student-centered application of contact zone theory also raises an important question: what happens when the instructor’s linguistic identity becomes a site of negotiation within the same space? Pratt (1991) defines contact zones as “social spaces where cultures meet, clash, and grapple with each other, often in contexts of highly asymmetrical relations of power” (p. 34). This definition suggests that contact zones are relational spaces shaped by interaction among all participants, rather than spaces experienced by students alone.

Beyond contact zone theory, a distinct body of scholarship has examined the experiences of non-native English-speaking teachers (NNESTs) and international teaching assistants (ITAs) directly. Moussu and Llurda (2008) synthesize decades of research on NNESTs, documenting how accent, native-speaker status, and perceived linguistic authority shape students’ evaluations of teacher competence, often independent of actual instructional skill (pp. 326–329). Much of this research, however, has approached NNESTs as an undifferentiated category; as Moussu and Llurda themselves observe, “research so far has typically approached NNSs as a single group” (p. 337), a limitation this study’s grounded, single-instructor account helps particularize rather than resolve.

Together, this body of work shows that challenges to the authority of multilingual instructors are not isolated experiences but well-documented across different disciplines and institutional settings. Research on non-native English-speaking teachers (NNESTs) and international teaching assistants (ITAs) has examined issues such as accent bias, oral proficiency testing, instructor evaluations, and institutional support. However, this scholarship has generally focused on student outcomes, evaluation practices, or institutional policies. This study builds on that work by bringing it into conversation with contact zone theory. Rather than viewing these issues as only administrative or pedagogical concerns, it argues that they are also examples of how authority is negotiated through language, identity, and power within the contact zone.

Recent scholarship on international teaching assistants extends this connection between accent and racialization directly. Ramjattan (2022) borrows the concept of “accent work” from the labor undergone by actors to adopt an accent for a role, applying it to ITAs whose accents are treated as “liabilities” in English-medium university classrooms (p. 1256). Ramjattan (2020) further demonstrates that ITAs are commonly “criticized for having ‘unintelligible’ accents for professional communication” (p. 1119), a criticism that “takes a racist form” by disproportionately targeting racially minoritized ITAs regardless of actual intelligibility. This scholarship places my experiences within a broader pattern of challenges faced by multilingual instructors, showing that they are not isolated incidents but part of a larger body of documented research.

While contact zone pedagogy expects instructors to guide students through linguistic difference, it rarely considers what happens when the instructor’s own linguistic identity becomes a source of scrutiny or misunderstanding. In these moments, authority cannot be assumed simply because of the instructor’s role. Instead, multilingual instructors may find themselves negotiating their own legitimacy within the same classroom they are expected to lead. This reveals an important limitation of contact zone pedagogy: it often assumes instructors occupy stable positions of linguistic authority, overlooking how that authority can be challenged for those whose speech falls outside dominant linguistic norms. My experience as a multilingual international graduate instructor illustrates how instructor authority is continually negotiated rather than automatically granted.

Recognizing the instructor as a participant in the contact zone is important because it challenges the assumption that classroom authority is stable and automatically comes with the instructor’s role. By focusing on multilingual international graduate instructors, this study shows how linguistic identity shapes perceptions of legitimacy, competence, and authority in ways that writing studies has often overlooked. While much of the scholarship has focused on how students negotiate power in the classroom, far less attention has been given to instructors’ own experiences of vulnerability and contested authority. Viewing the contact zone in this way also raises an important methodological question: how can these experiences be studied from the instructor’s perspective? Because these moments of negotiation are deeply personal and often difficult to capture through observation or surveys alone, this study uses critical autoethnography to examine how authority, linguistic legitimacy, and belonging are experienced and negotiated in the classroom.