Xchanging Ideas through Xchanges: Revisiting Selected Articles to Understand Graduate Teaching Assistants’ Pedagogical Praxis
by Jainab Tabassum Banu | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Learning from Xchanges: Key Pedagogical Interventions
As an international graduate student reader, I identified a number of scholarly articles written by other contributors who were graduate students or early-career academics at the time of publishing, such as Nasih Alam, Jennifer Hewerdine, and Elizabeth Bracey. What distinguished their articles for me was their ability to bridge scholarly inquiry and lived pedagogical experience. Rather than presenting abstract discussions of teaching, the authors theorized classroom practices they had personally navigated, making their insights both accessible and transferable. Their reflections resonated with my own experiences as an international graduate teaching assistant and gave me greater confidence to adapt, question, and refine my own pedagogical practices. As a researcher whose work draws on autoethnographic methods, I also found their reflective mode of inquiry intellectually validating. It also reinforces my understanding that lived experience can serve as a rigorous site of knowledge production.
Navigating Identity and Positionality: Insights from Alam’s Essay
Nasih Alam’s autoethnographic essay, “An International Graduate Teaching Student’s First Year as a First-Year Writing Instructor” (April 2024), employs an autoethnographic approach to document his personal and professional journey from enduring a strict education system in Bangladesh to becoming a student-centered First-Year Writing instructor at North Dakota State University. His piece highlights the emotional, identity, and linguistic navigation required of international Graduate Teaching Assistants, advocating for the integration of diverse cultural backgrounds and translingual identities into pedagogies that foster empathy and linguistic justice.
As I read this article, I situate myself as an international graduate teaching assistant (IGTA) navigating first-year writing instruction at a midwestern research university. At the time I first engaged with Alam’s essay, I was teaching both first-year and upper-division writing courses within our writing program. Across these contexts, my instructor identity that is shaped by linguistic, cultural, and academic positionalities played a central role in how I approached teaching. Alam’s reflections on navigating classroom expectations, institutional norms, and student interactions resonated deeply with my own lived and embodied experiences. His essay offers both validation and a lens through which I could interpret the challenges and possibilities of teaching as an IGTA.
Alam’s reflection on his traumatic childhood experiences seemed familiar to the context I came from. He describes how, like many children in his cultural context, he was physically punished for minor mistakes. This is a longstanding trauma, as he notes, took years to process (1). For international graduate teaching assistants (IGTAs), engaging students in discussions of race and racial oppression in predominantly white classrooms can be similarly daunting. Drawing on the work of Grayson and Inoue, Alam emphasizes the importance of selecting reading materials that “raise awareness of racism and create an engaging classroom atmosphere,” enabling students to reflect critically on oppression and “raise their voice against white oppression in writing” (2). He further suggests that assignments such as personal narratives or memoirs can provide students with structured opportunities to develop racial understanding and literacy. Yet, as Alam implicitly acknowledges that facilitating such engagement is neither straightforward nor simple.
Alam’s experience with controversial topics such as racism and racial literacy deeply resonated with my own experience as an IGTA. As of early 2026, over twenty states have enacted restrictions or bans on critical race theory (CRT) and so-called “divisive concepts,” primarily through legislation, with nearly thirty states having introduced some form of restriction. Although these measures and changes target K-12 education, they have direct implications for college teaching and pedagogical praxis. For international graduate teaching assistants like Alam and myself, this dual responsibility to understand both the content we teach and the legal or institutional constraints that shape how we teach it is particularly crucial.
His caution in avoiding sensitive topics such as “gun violence” or “abortion” (2) reflects this tension. His reflection that “if my students had a more courageous teacher in my place, they would have found more opportunities to develop their critical thinking abilities” (2) underscores a critical concern. His hesitation is not due to a lack of pedagogical skill or capacity to facilitate complex discussions, but rather it stems from the real stakes of his positionality as a non-resident alien navigating U.S. institutional and legal structures for pursuing higher education. This complex context highlights the layered challenges IGTAs face. I completely resonate with Alam’s reflection as my own experience as an IGTA caused me imposter syndromes and a persistent sense of dislocation in a culture that simultaneously ignites fear and freedom.
Under the pressure of staying on the safe side, IGTAs often must unlearn the assumption that writing is primarily a product and that grammar constitutes the most important pillar of English composition. This orientation frequently stems from experiences learning English as an additional language. In many educational systems where English is taught as an additional language, students and even teachers tend to prioritize grammatical accuracy over critical engagement or rhetorical complexity.
Like Alam, I initially struggled with the tendency to focus on students’ grammatical and stylistic errors. However, reading his essay helped me recognize that “the academic rapport between graduate teaching assistants and first-year writers is needed to bridge the communication gap” (4). Once I began prioritizing rapport-building, students’ grammatical mistakes became secondary in my feedback, and their embodied and affective engagement with writing came to surface. Alam notes that he draws on his own experiences and stories as examples. While I find this approach inspiring, as a female international graduate teaching assistant, I also see a loophole in his article. As his article is written through a personal narrative lens, he could not bring different experiences faced by diverse IGTA. For instance, as a female IGTA, I often feel doubly constrained: first by my gender and then by my positionality as an IGTA. This historical suppression complicates my pedagogical voice, and I am still in the process of making that voice fully heard in the classroom and in my research through feminist pedagogical and research practices.
What genuinely stood out to me in Alam’s essay is his “recommendation” section, with which I wholeheartedly agree. First, he advises writing programs and associated administrators such as directors and assistant directors to “understand that many of the IGTAs have little experience with the U.S. educational system and are shy of speaking about their hesitation when they begin studying at their chosen graduate program” (6), and cautions against assuming that graduate assistants “are supposed to have a clear understanding of the primary text” (6). I have experienced this firsthand. As IGTAs, we are often perceived as field experts even while we are still learning to teach writing and refine our own scholarly skills. Alam notes, “It becomes mentally draining for IGTAs to start performing well from scratch” (6), highlighting an additional layer in the already complex challenges we face.
Second, Alam’s direct acknowledgment of shyness particularly resonated with me. Initially, I hesitated to share my own concerns with my writing program director. His essay encouraged me to step out of my comfort zone, advocate for support, and recognize that while a program may be empathetic, seeking accommodation and guidance remains my responsibility as a member of that community. In this way, Alam’s essay exemplifies the unique value of Xchanges as a digital pedagogical archive as it preserves experiences that can be reinterpreted through multiple lenses while providing ongoing guidance for fellow IGTAs.
Engaging with Alam’s work helped me develop confidence in my identity as an IGTA and strengthened my embodied, intersectional, and transnational pedagogical perspective. Concurrently, I was experimenting with my own writing courses by moving beyond traditional essays toward multimodal and digital projects. In this context, Jennifer Hewerdine’s essay on blog-based writing immediately captured my attention.
Multimodal Composition in Practice: Insights from Hewerdine’s Pilot Study
Jennifer Hewerdine’s essay, “Exploring the Benefits of Blog Use in First-Year Composition: A Pilot Study” (May 2021), offers a compelling framework for integrating blog writing as a multimodal supplement in first-year composition courses. Recognizing that contemporary students are deeply engaged in digital environments, she argues that blogs provide authentic opportunities for students to compose for public audiences while integrating multiple modes of communication, including images, videos, hyperlinks, and audio. Drawing on survey data from students in technology-enhanced composition courses, Hewerdine finds that blogging fosters greater audience awareness, agency, ownership, and metacognitive reflection than conventional writing assignments. Rather than treating digital technologies as supplementary tools, she positions blogs as rhetorical spaces where students negotiate identity, purpose, and audience through multimodal composing, illustrating how digital writing can promote process-based learning and more meaningful engagement with writing.
Writing in the context of the classroom after 2020 COVID-19, Hewerdine observes, as I observed too, that “the current generation of students chooses to spend liberal amounts of time in online environments” (1). This shift, as we have noticed, has significantly reshaped students’ expectations of engagement and participation. I have witnessed this transformation as well. After prolonged exposure to digital learning during the pandemic, students increasingly seek forms of writing that feel meaningful, interactive, and worth their time. As Hewerdine notes, students are more likely to participate when they are “mentally stimulated” by activities that align with their interests (1). To help students work on something that matters to them, as Alam suggested in his article, it is important for the instructors to be confident and get rid of shyness and design lesson plans and assignments as Hewerdine did confidently.
To contextualize her study, Hewerdine refers to Ivanic’s framework outlining the diverse qualities of students’ extracurricular writing, thereby foregrounding the importance of digital rhetoric in contemporary writing practices. Drawing from this understanding, blog writing emerges as a particularly flexible and multimodal genre that “allow[s] writers to incorporate pictures, videos, hyperlinks, music, and other audio elements,” enabling communication across multiple modes (2). This emphasis on multimodality expands the definition of writing and invites students to engage with composition as a dynamic and public-facing practice. I agree with Hewerdine’s emphasis that “composition instructors can use blogs to take advantage of tools that provide for a variety of communication methods” (2) by highlighting the affordances of blogs as multimodal writing.
In her pilot study, conducted across two composition courses set in “technology-enhanced computer classrooms,” (3) Hewerdine gathered data from thirty-one student participants and analyzed their responses to blog-based writing tasks. Her findings identify four key constructs that students approached differently in blog writing compared to traditional formats: “public audience awareness, agency, ownership, and metacognitive use” (4). These constructs highlight how blogging shifts writing from a purely academic exercise to a more dynamic, reflective, and audience-centered practice. As Hewerdine’s analysis demonstrates, blog writing encourages students to engage with a real or imagined public audience, develop a stronger sense of authorial agency, and take ownership of their ideas. At the same time, the process of composing in multimodal environments fosters metacognitive awareness as it prompts students to reflect on their rhetorical choices and writing processes. In this sense, teaching blogs functions as a pedagogical tool that aligns closely with traditional process-based approaches to writing instruction. Moreover, as she suggests, blogging enables students to represent their identities within digital spaces, designing arguments that integrate textual, visual, and digital elements. This multimodal engagement expands the scope of composition and allows students to experience writing as an iterative, recursive and expressive process rather than a fixed, product-oriented task.
As an instructor who views writing as a means of articulating and circulating ideas beyond the classroom, I found Hewerdine’s approach both generative and transferrable. Personally, I began incorporating blog writing assignments in both first-year and upper-division professional writing courses. In first-year writing, introducing blogs as a replacement for traditional final commentary papers was relatively seamless, as students loved the format because it is public-facing, less academic and, in a way, liberating for student writers.
In professional writing courses, however, I found it necessary to more deliberately scaffold the assignment by framing blog writing as a legitimate and widely used professional genre. Drawing on my understanding of digital rhetoric which I developed through my engagement with scholarly works, including Hewerdine’s essay, I guide students to make purposeful rhetorical choices, such as selecting appropriate images and embedding credible hyperlinks to produce legible and persuasive public-facing texts. In this context, Hewerdine’s essay functioned less as a source to cite and more as a form of pedagogical mentorship, validating my approach while strengthening the theoretical and practical rationale behind it.
While Alam’s essay reassured my identity as an IGTA in a U.S. writing classroom, Hewerdine’s essay ultimately extended beyond my classroom practice. Building on my pedagogical experiments in blogs and multimodal writing, I later published a teaching-focused article on blog writing as a professional genre in the Journal of Response to Writing. In this way, Hewerdine’s work contributed to my development as a scholar. This reinforces the role of Xchanges as a space where experience-based pedagogical insights circulate, evolve, and generate new forms of knowledge production.
As my identity as an IGTA became more grounded and my pedagogical innovations took shape, I found myself returning to one of the most critical yet often overlooked aspects of writing: revision. While revision is commonly understood as the final stage in which writers refine their language and argument before submission, Elizabeth Bracey’s work reframes revision as an ongoing, recursive process central to writing itself. Engaging with her article prompted me to reconsider how I pedagogically approached revision in my own courses.
Re-centering Revision as Process: Insights from Bracey’s Essay
Elizabeth Bracey’s essay, “The Will to Revise: Commenting, Revision, and Motivation in College Students,” examines the relationship between pedagogical practice and student motivation, with particular attention to how instructor feedback shapes students’ willingness to revise. Drawing on scholarship by Nancy Sommers, Barry Zimmerman, Frank Anson, and others, Bracey argues that effective revision depends not only on the quality of teacher comments but also on students’ sense of agency and motivation. Through surveys, draft analysis, and student reflections, she finds that many students treat instructor comments as directives rather than opportunities for critical decision-making, leading them to prioritize compliance over substantive revision. Bracey therefore calls for pedagogical practices that encourage students to view revision as a recursive learning process, fostering greater ownership, academic authority, and independence as writers rather than simply satisfying instructors’ expectations.
Bracey’s discussion resonated with my own educational and teaching experiences. Coming from a context where English writing instruction largely emphasized grammatical correctness, I initially understood revision as the process of correcting language and polishing sentences. Feedback, likewise, was often confined to sentence-level or stylistic corrections rather than broader rhetorical concerns. As a result, revision became synonymous with editing instead of rethinking ideas, organization, audience, and purpose. Bracey’s essay challenged this understanding by repositioning revision as an intellectual and rhetorical activity rather than a mechanical one. Her work helped me realize that effective feedback should not merely improve a draft but should also motivate students to return to their writing with renewed purpose and confidence.
Bracey’s discussion of student dependence on instructor comments captured my attention. She notes that because students often internalize their instructors’ expectations, they “may develop a sense of dependence on instruction and commenting that may impede their ability to revise on their own” (1). I have observed this tendency in my own classrooms. While I regularly encouraged students to question or challenge my feedback when it did not align with their rhetorical intentions, many tended to conform to my comments, opting for safer, minimal revisions before submitting their final drafts. In attempting to guide their writing, I realized that I might have unintentionally limited their sense of authority and agency as writers. This pattern revealed an important pedagogical tension. While feedback is intended to support student writers, it can inadvertently diminish their sense of authority if students perceive instructor comments as commands rather than opportunities for rhetorical decision-making.
I feel that Bracey’s argument has become even more significant in the era of generative AI. Today, students can instantly turn to AI tools to edit or “polish” their writing, revise grammar, sentence structure, and style with AI-assisted writing tools, making it increasingly easy to equate revision with surface-level correction. These responses further complicate the process of revision, raising important questions about student motivation, responsibility, and the evolving role of feedback in contemporary writing classrooms.
One of the most valuable contributions of Bracey’s study is her identification of a gap in existing scholarship concerning “the role of commenting in creating motivation for students to revise their work carefully” (p. 2, para. 6). As both a reader and a writing instructor, I found this argument compelling. When we comment on student writing, we do not simply point out what is lacking—we aim to encourage students to recognize those gaps and take ownership of revising their work. Bracy shifts the focus from revision as a mechanical process to revision as a motivated, reflective act shaped by both instructor feedback and student engagement. She discusses her observation which resonates with my own classroom experience, particularly her observation that students often interpret instructor comments as “commands” to be followed rather than as invitations to rethink their writing. Revision essentially means “re-thinking” or “re-viewing”. I have witnessed similar patterns where students prioritize addressing my feedback over engaging with their own ideas. They write about their revision by addressing how they incorporated my feedback into their writing instead of revisiting their thoughts and words.
This tendency raises an important pedagogical tension. While feedback is intended to guide and support, it can inadvertently undermine students’ sense of authority and ownership over their writing. Bracey’s findings pushed me to reconsider not only what I comment on, but how I frame those comments. Inspired by her discussion, I adopted Bill Hart-Davidson’s “describe-evaluate-suggest” feedback model to provide students with actionable guidance while leaving space for their own rhetorical choices. Rather than prescribing revisions, I ask open-ended questions that encourage students to explain, reconsider, and develop their arguments. I also shifted my assessment practices by awarding points for sustained engagement with the revision process rather than emphasizing grades on final products. These changes reflect three enduring pedagogical commitments that I drew from Bracey’s essay: (i) revision should be understood as rhetorical inquiry rather than grammatical correction; (ii) instructor feedback should cultivate student agency rather than compliance; and (iii) assessment should motivate reflective revision instead of rewarding only polished products. These commitments have reshaped how I teach writing and how I understand revision as the core of process-based composition.
