|

Reflecting on & Reimagining Feminism in Rhetoric and Composition: From Graduate School to the Professoriate

by Sarah Fischer and Megan McCool | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026

Reimaginings

In case we have not yet made this clear in the article so far: we understand feminism as a body of scholarship within and beyond rhetoric and composition, but also–and especially pertinent to this article–as a value system that guides how we move through our daily lives, including our academic spaces. Through our reflections, we have each identified key practices that are critical to enacting feminism in rhetoric and composition. Sarah discusses rhetorical listening, reflexivity, and revision, and Megan expands on these practices by considering responsivity and positive gatekeeping. We understand these values and practices as allowing us to reimagine a more intersectional feminism and a more collaborative feminism.

As we move from reflecting on our previous ideas to reimagining these ideas moving forward, we find it important to note that our reimaginings are still in process. They are not perfect nor are they finalized. As such, we do not seek to include these reimaginings as a final “answer” to the issues we now recognize in “Doing it Herself.” Rather we view our reimaginings as a feminist practice of acknowledging and working through the tensions, imperfections, and complexities that make up this kind of work. Feminism has allowed us to imperfectly reimagine the affordances, constraints, and tensions that arise in feminist work. As Gay (2014) argues in Bad Feminist, it is important to “reconcile the imperfections” of feminism in order to still focus on “all the good it can do” (p. x). By reimagining all the good that feminism can do, we hope to better work toward a world in which people of all genders have equal opportunities in all areas of their lives.

Sarah’s Reimaginings

While the field’s definition of feminism is multiple and still evolving, there are three key practices that I believe have served as, and will continue to serve as, critical to enacting feminism in rhetoric and composition: rhetorical listening, reflexivity, and revision. These values allow us to reimagine a more intersectional feminism and are informed by feminist writings from scholars in the discipline who write about concepts like rhetorical listening (Garcia, 2019; Glenn and Ratcliffe, 2011; Ratcliffe, 1999; Ratcliffe and Jensen, 2022) reflection and reflexivity (Acosta et al., 2026; Ahmed, 2014; Cedillo, 2018; Kirsch & Royster, 2010; Kirsch & Ritchie, 1995; Knoblauch, 2012; Sicari, 2019;), and revision (Glenn, 2018; Kirsch & Sullivan, 1992). In this section, I discuss how I carry out these feminist practices, especially in my research. I focus first on the feminist framework I employed in a body chapter of my dissertation. Then, I discuss the way I use these practices in my current research as an assistant professor.

I understand these three values as interrelated. They are united by common practices of critical interrogation of one’s own positionality/embodiment and common goals of better understanding others, especially across difference. Rhetorical listening is a “way of helping continually negotiate our always evolving standpoints, our identities, with the always evolving standpoints of others” (Ratcliffe, 1999, p. 209). Reflexivity, then, aids in rhetorical listening as it allows us to systematically and rigorously contemplate our own bodies and the way they move through the world–especially the times and places they move with frictionless privilege. Finally, revision is what results from our rhetorical listening and reflexivity. When we listen deeply, not for our own personal gain but to truly “stand under” (Ratcliffe, 1999) and reflect on our own beings and our “politics of location” (Kirsch & Ritchie, 1995), we can realize shortcomings, oversights, and inaccuracies. And more, we can course correct by taking accountability and revising, demonstrating that we “are not afraid to go back, rethink, revise, [and] forge ahead” with hope that our ideas, and our discipline, “will eventually blossom with intellectual and academic respect and equality” (Glenn, 2018, p. 138).

In my dissertation, I examined YouTube vlogs through multiple methodologies, including making vlogs of my own, assigning vlogs as major projects in writing classes, and–as I discuss in more detail here–analyzing popular vlogs on YouTube as case studies. Rhetorical analysis is a long-standing practice in Rhetoric in Composition; as researchers, we employ it in our scholarship to make new arguments or address existing ones, and as instructors, we teach our students to practice it, too. However, because of the field’s struggles to clearly articulate method/ologies (Holmes & Hurley, 2024; VanKooten & Del Hierro, 2022), rhetorical analysis felt not only too broad but also ethically fraught when attempting to use it in my dissertation. Analyzing vloggers’ productions of their lives and their bodies via video felt like it flattened them as people, failing to fully account for their intersectional identities, and overlooked the multiple kinds of labor that go into producing a vlog–labor(s) that I know first-hand. Inspired in part by Meagan E. Malone’s analysis of popular YouTube video essayist Natalie Wynn ], I decided to employ a particular approach to my rhetorical analysis–one that was rooted in feminist values of rhetorical listening, reflexivity, and revision. Like Malone models in “Embracing the Potentials and Navigating the Pitfalls of Interdisciplinary Method/olodgies” (2024), I distilled a feminist framework for analysis from Kirsch and Royster’s 2010 article, “Feminist Rhetorical Practices: In Search of Excellence,” to analyze YouTube vlogs. Following Malone’s lead, I used Kirsch and Royster’s feminist practices, rooted in rhetorical listening, reflexivity, and revision to analyze YouTube videos more systematically and intentionally.

This framework helped guide my analysis in more rigorous and, ultimately, more feminist ways. With Kirsch and Royster’s framework, my analysis became grounded in rhetorical listening, as I “deeply and respectfully listen[ed]” (Kirsch & Royster, 2010, p. 649) to each artifact, working not to impose my own perspectives but to “speculate…what might likely be true based on what we have on hand” (Kirsch & Royster, 2010, p. 650). At the same time, their framework encouraged me to acknowledge my own positionality and inherently impartial perspectives. Throughout my analysis, I used Kirsch and Royster as a guide to continually reflect on my own embodiment and the way it led me to make certain interpretations and, at times, precluded me from making other interpretations. Specifically, I was able to reflect on aspects of my embodiment and lived experiences that aligned or varied from the YouTubers who I analyzed, namely my whiteness, my fluency in only one language, and that I do not have children. This kind of intentional, strategic, continuous, and rigorous reflexivity allows for more intersectional feminism–the kind of feminism we aspire for but failed to reach in “Doing It Herself.”

Furthermore, modeling what Kirsch and Royster do in their article, I included “Reflection” sections at the end of each case study. Here, I returned to my analysis months after initially conducting it, and reflected on my reflections, with the privilege of time and distance to see new things and make revisions where necessary. Enacting feminism within rhetoric and composition means continuously revising previous writing and thinking, especially your own, and it means constantly re-interrogating one’s positionality and privilege in that thinking and writing. It is this very kind of feminist revision that we hope to enact in this current article.

Now, as an assistant professor, I am working on refashioning my dissertation into a book. These feminist practices of rhetorical listening, reflexivity, and revision are still just as critical for me as I “look and look again, listen and listen again, [and] think and think again” (Kirsch & Royster, 2010, p. 652) about my methodologies and their ethical implications. While adding a feminist framework to my analysis helped alleviate some of my research anxieties, the practice of analysis altogether still feels ethically flawed. For lifestyle vlogs in particular, where people (often women) display their bodies, their homes, and their lives as public and consumable content, analysis does not feel like enough. With analysis, I feel, as Ramos (2016) says, I am “transform[ing] people into objects.” In order to more fully rhetorically listen–especially to empathetically hear across difference–I must have these vloggers’ own voices.

One approach I am exploring for the book is video-based interviews with vloggers, where vlogger’s own voices and bodies can speak for themselves. This approach demonstrates a more intersectional kind of knowledge-making since I will not serve as the sole contributor of knowledge. By featuring multiple perspectives, with their own bodies and voices on screen, I can show vloggers from multiple subject positions–including marginalized and multiply marginalized positions–without filtering them through the lens of my own whiteness, and hetero-cisgendered womanhood. Replacing analysis of public artifacts with video-based interviews requires extra time and labor that is not always easily afforded on the tenure track, but it is a more feminist approach I would not be attempting without rhetorically listening to feminist scholars and mentors, reflecting on my previous writing/thinking, and revising old ideas with new insights I’ve gleaned.

Megan’s Reimaginings

As I described in my “Reflections” section, relation-relating is a feminist practice that continues to be central to the research I do in rhetoric and composition. Now, though, I think about relation-relating through the lens of feminist collaboration. I do not see these two concepts as mutually exclusive, but rather I am now reimagining the ways that relation-relating for feminist aims requires thoughtful, careful collaboration. In reflecting on “Doing It Herself,” I find myself reimagining how an individualistic approach to feminist relation-relating is not only untenable for feminism, but it is also contradictory. When considering the various relationships that emerge when engaging in feminism, many in rhetoric and composition have explored the important role that collaboration plays (Glenn, 2018; Micciche, 2010; Nickoson & Sheridan, 2012; Royster & Kirsch, 2012;). In other words, we cannot do the work of feminism without feminist collaboration. Using my experiences with community writing to ground me, in this section I describe what feminist collaboration has come to mean to me and outline two rhetorical practices that have helped me enact feminist collaboration.

As I mentioned above, my research is focused on theories and pedagogies of community-engaged writing, specifically within contexts of gender-based violence prevention. Key questions I am interested in are, what kinds of partnerships are possible between students and survivors? And, how can these partnerships help us further theorize community writing? While I was writing in the genre of a dissertation, a genre that demands single authorship and work that needs to be completed in a strict timeframe, I was also writing for the field of community writing, an area of study that demands research be developed from relationships with community partners, is reciprocal rather than extractive, and is co-created rather than imposed (CCCC, 2023). The demands of the genre of a dissertation which requires an individualistic approach to scholarship, and the demands of the field of community writing which centers research that is collaborative, are in many ways incongruous.

I suggest that feminist collaboration is one approach for navigating these incongruities; I do not, however, see this practice as one that is straightforward or without its own complexities. For example, when navigating a feminist approach to collaboration in my dissertation research, I had to consider relationships between myself, students, and community organizations. I also had to consider students’ relationships to the social issue that grounded our work: issues of gender-based violence such as domestic violence, sexual assault, and human trafficking. For many readers, the complicated ethical dynamics of this work make themselves immediately clear. As a researcher who brings feminist theory to community writing (in large part because of the social issue with which I was working), I had to acknowledge the complicated ethical and relational dynamics involved in this work, and a feminist approach to collaboration was one framework that helped me do so. For example, I needed to consider how to maintain reciprocal relationships with my community partners, the ways that my pedagogical research could be collaborative with my students, and also what kinds of collaborative writing were possible between students and the community partners with whom they were being asked to work.

Through reflecting on both my earlier work writing “Doing It Herself,” as well as by reflecting on my dissertation research, I have noted two feminist rhetorical practices that have been useful for my work with feminist collaboration and that might also be useful for others in theirs: responsivity and positive gatekeeping. In many ways, I see these practices as complementary to and extensions of Sarah’s discussion of rhetorical listening, reflexivity, and revision. By providing these additional approaches to feminism, I hope to equip readers with additional examples of feminist values and practices that can be used for the various contexts in which we work.

Responsivity is a practice rooted in feminist values while also being a central practice of community-engaged writing. Sheridan (2018) writes that responsivity “challenge[s] standardized practices” of collaboration “in favor of supple, situated interactions based on the current needs of those within specific communities and publics” (p. xi). Additionally, Royster (2014) explains that “a rhetoric of responsivity [is] a way of being and a way of doing” (p. 288) in which rhetoricians can build “cross-sectional collaborations in local urban contexts that permit us to see and work as academics in ways that are intellectually robust, responsive to contemporary problems and issues, and also responsive to the diversity of the human beings involved” (p. 283).

In my dissertation work, this looked like being responsive to the capacities of community partners. While much of community writing scholarship argues for the importance of designing community-university partnerships collaboratively with community organizations, the practice of responsivity gives feminist researchers one specific way to approach these collaborations. When discussing options for a collaboration between my writing students and one nonprofit organization that I had been working with for years, it turned out that my initial goals for the partnerships did not align with the organization’s needs and capacity for collaboration. While I was hoping for a deeply collaborative partnership in which students were writing with the organization and its clients, the organization most needed students to provide direct service work that supported the daily operations of their survivor-centered programming. Community writing has long cautioned against the kinds of partnerships that this nonprofit desired (see CCCC, 2023; Morton, 1995; Restaino & Cella, 2013), so though I was initially hesitant to continue our collaboration, I chose to be responsive to the goals and capacities of my partner organization.

This responsivity led me to rethink the possibilities for this kind of community writing partnership and to consider how I could help students ethically engage in this work in ways that did not reinforce a charity-oriented or savior-minded approach to social change and instead could contribute to more ethical and inclusive feminist social change.

As I develop new partnerships with community organizations in my role as an assistant professor, building relationships grounded in mutual trust and respect with nonprofit organizations in new settings and tentatively outlining what a collaboration between them, myself, and my students might look like, reminds me of the importance of enacting responsivity, which prioritizes situated, responsive approaches to working with others rather than standardized ones. Practicing responsivity reminds me that the ways I have collaborated with others in the past do not automatically translate to my present. Or, that sometimes these collaborations might involve taking risks that go against the standardized approach. In a time marked by attacks on the public funding structures that support much nonprofit work, now more than ever it is important to be responsive to the always evolving needs and capacities of community partners.

Additionally, collaborating with others for feminist aims also brings up the issue of when it is necessary to practice what Itchuaqiyaq et al. (2022) call positive gatekeeping. In their 2022 symposium for the Community Literacy Journal on protecting community members from the demands of the university for access to people, communities, and lands, Itchuaqiyaq et al. argue that the idea of access is often seen as an unquestioned good (2022, p. 94). In other words, it is commonly thought that the more accessible peoples, communities, and land is to university researchers for collaboration, the better for all groups involved. Rather than considering opening up access to communities, lands, and peoples as always good, they instead suggest that this kind of access puts communities “at risk of exploitation” (2022, p. 95). As a way to mitigate this risk, they suggest that academics can exercise a “positive gatekeeping function” in which researchers serve as a “precursor to exploitation” (2022, p. 94).

In my dissertation research, positive gatekeeping looked like not only being responsive to the needs of community partners but also preemptively considering the kinds of harm both partners and students might face in collaborative work centered around gender-based violence prevention. For instance, one organization with whom students worked was a coalitional group made up of local and state governmental commissioners and nonprofit organizations that supported gender justice generally but also had programming focused on gender-based violence prevention specifically. Because of the nature of this organization and the work they are involved with, as well as their eagerness to work with student writers at the university, I found it important to provide some guardrails for this partnership that honored the capacities and labor of this coalitional organization. I did not want to take advantage of the kinds of access they were offering students, so I worked to ensure that our collaboration together honored the other roles and responsibilities of these community partners and did not add an unreasonable amount of additional labor to their already heavy work loads.

Additionally, I had to consider the well-being of students, and the kinds of access to their own personal mental and emotional bandwidths they would need to give to community partners in this context. To navigate this, I always ensured that students were given a choice on the kinds of community-engaged work in which they participated, and I worked to implement trauma-informed pedagogy in my classroom. Moving forward in my research, I am continuing to consider the ways that I, as a community writing researcher, can ensure that the access I am asking for—access to community organizations, access to the lives of survivors, and to students’ mental and emotional bandwidths—is never assumed nor taken for granted. I am continuing to think about what kinds of collaborations are possible between survivors and students and the ways that I can serve as a positive gatekeeper for both groups of people.

When engaging in collaborative feminist work for positive social change, it is essential to be attuned to the various positionalities of those with whom one is working. Echoing Sarah’s calls for an intersectional approach to feminism, by serving as a positive gatekeeper in one’s community-engaged partnerships, we can better navigate the ethical and relational complexities that exist below the surface of our work. On the other hand, even when collaborative feminist spaces exist and limiting unfettered access to institutionally disadvantaged groups can be beneficial, particularly in contexts of community writing, feminist scholars in rhetoric and composition remind us of the importance of being attuned to who has access to feminist collaboration and thus collective social change in the first place (Chavez, 2013; Licona, 2013; Royster & Kirsch, 2012). To ensure access to feminist collaboration and coalitional work is possible, those from more privileged positions must reflect on and reimagine more thoughtful ways to center the experiences of folks who have been historically left out of feminist social change work.

In seeking to navigate these dilemmas as ethically as possible, feminist approaches to collaboration helped guide me. While I know there is no ethically pure way to navigate this work, I would like to think that feminist theories and approaches to collaboration helped me mitigate the harm that could have been caused. Because, for me, feminist collaboration is not just about “relation-relating” as a way to build community, but rather, feminist collaboration is centered around the fact that we are always already in relationship with others when we do feminist rhetorical work. As a result, we must always be aware of how feminism helps us recognize and respond to the ways that collaborative relationships always require us to examine one’s positionality and relationships, or our embodiment as Sarah would say, to those with whom we are collaborating, and all of the ethical tensions that come up as a result.