Reflecting on & Reimagining Feminism in Rhetoric and Composition: From Graduate School to the Professoriate
by Sarah Fischer and Megan McCool | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
Reflections
Though we entertained several themes upon which to reflect here, two overarching themes prevailed. First, we realized that our conception of feminism in âDoing it Herselfâ was far too narrow. Aside from a few sentences in the conclusion that acknowledge our whiteness, we did not seriously contend with intersecting identities and their importance to and for feminism. Our understanding of feminism was a predominantly white understanding, and if âintersectionality is the marrow within the bones of feminismâ (Gay, 2013), then what we were after wasnât really feminism at all. In her reflections section, Sarah elaborates on the theme of intersectionality as it relates to her research on embodiment and social media. Additionally, the second theme that emerged was that our understanding of feminism was concerningly individualistic. Although we acknowledge the concept of ârelation-relatingâ in the original article, we failed to understand the ways in which true feminism extends beyond individuals and small groups of friends. In her reflections section, Megan explains the importance of feminist approaches to collaboration by situating it in her research on community writing and gender-based violence prevention.
Sarahâs Reflections
One thing Megan has always been good at reminding me is: âtwo things can be true.â This reminder has been especially helpful when thinking about my definitions of scholarship. In my first year of graduate school, my understanding of academic, peer-reviewed scholarship was writing that was neutral, objective, and ultimately, what today Iâd called disembodied. When receiving our invitation to submit a manuscript in 2019, I was surprised to learn that the editors wanted to read a narrative-based piece for a peer-reviewed journal. Even after our article was published, as I was updating my CV, I asked my coauthors if I was âreally allowedâ to place the Xchanges article under the âPeer-Reviewed Journal Articlesâ heading because âitâs just a narrative piece.â However, two things can be true. Scholarship can be the traditional disembodied writing, but it can also beâand Iâd argue is often better when it isâfully embodied. In this section, I explain how our original Xchanges article, especially as it was my first publication, prompted me to rethink the role of embodiment, embodied knowledge, and embodied rhetoric in academic writing.
As I continued to develop my research interests in coursework and beyond, I found myself gravitating towards scholarship that used first-person language and reflected on lived experiences (Calafell, 2010; Cedillo, 2018; Hidalgo, 2017; Vieira, 2019). In particular, I was struck by scholarsâ âcommitment to exercising the critical self-reflexivity and questioning that is a hallmark feature of feminist researchâ (Schell & Rawson, 2010, p. 18). While previous academic training had taught me that these feminist commitments were at best not academic and at worst solipsistic or even narcissistic, these feminist scholars showed me the intellectual and ethical value in critical self-reflexivity, including critically self-reflecting on oneâs own lived experiences. Put simply: feminists in rhetoric and composition taught me that lived experience is a legitimate form of knowledge. And I would soon learn how to extend and leverage this knowledge.
With more time and more deep reading in the field, I began to understand this kind of scholarship that emphasizes the personal, the felt emotions, and the lived experiences as belonging to the larger subfield of Embodied Rhetorics. In her seminal article, âBodies of Knowledge: Definitions, Delineations, and Implications of Embodied Writing in the Academy,â Knoblauch (2012) offers three categories of embodiment upon which rhetoric and composition scholars are often focused when discussing embodiment: embodied language, embodied knowledge, and embodied rhetoric. Embodied language involves metaphors related to the body and its senses and sensations. Embodied knowledge pertains to using oneâs body, including oneâs emotions and lived experiences, to make meaning. Embodied rhetoric, for which Knoblauch advocates, is more complex. It involves âa purposeful decision to include embodied knowledge and social positionalities as forms of meaning making within a text itselfâ (Knoblauch, 2012, p. 52). In other words, embodied rhetoric is when the writer explores how their body affects their writing and subsequently implements those reflections into the writing itself. This idea of embodied rhetoric âprovide[s] concrete strategies for enacting [the foundational ideals of] Adrienne Richâs call for a politics of location in writingâ (Knoblauch, 2012, p. 52). This kind of rigorous reflection asks the writer to think beyond their own emotions and lived experiences and to situate them within larger contexts that consider the material effects of sociocultural factors like gender, race, class, ability, and sexuality.
Knoblauchâs (2012) delineations give me the language to explain some of the lack of nuance of our original Xchanges article. In âDoing It Herself,â we relied on embodied knowledge, rather than embodied rhetoric, to narrate our experiences. Focusing on our individual lived experiences, without fully zooming out to reflect on our (privileged) positionalities, allowed us to elide crucial embodied differences and, ultimately, to produce what Megan and I feel reflects a problematically narrow conception of feminism. Glenn (2018) elaborates on this idea and articulates what is at stake if it continues:
âNo one assumes only one identity. We cannot consider the needs of women without also accounting for race, ethnicity, gender, citizenship, class, sexuality, ability, and more. Such nuanced awareness, such intersectionality, is the âmarrow within the bones of feminism.â Without it, feminism will fracture even further. (âLooking,â par. 6)â (p. 56)
Though we aimed to advance feminist goals, by not engaging in deeper reflections on our positionalitiesâby not practicing embodied rhetoricâwe were allowing feminism to fracture.
I am not arguing that embodied knowledge is not valuable. Using oneâs body and bodily senses to make meaning is crucial to the discipline, especially in multimodal settings, as emphasized by scholars like Steph Ceraso, Jody Shipka, Anne Frances Wysocki, and Kristin Arola. I am arguing that in the context of our original article, embodied rhetoric would have propelled our embodied knowledge further and taken us closer to achieving our feminist goals. By reflecting on our experiences as female graduate students in male-dominated courses and curriculum, alongside critical reflections of our white, hetero-cisgendered, and able bodies, we could have worked towards a more accurate depiction of feminismâone that aligns with rhetoric and compositionâs definition of feminism as necessarily inclusive and intersectional.
These ideas, about 1) lived experiences as valuable feminist knowledge and 2) embodied rhetoric as a framework for self-reflexively interrogating my lived experiences, informed my dissertation project as a graduate student and continue to inform my research as an assistant professor today. Because of the way âDoing It Herselfâ opened new possibilities for the way I understand scholarship, I undertook projects that place embodiment and lived experiences at the center. Specifically, I research lifestyle vlogs and their relationship to rhetorical awareness, and I incorporate autoethnographic approaches as I draw on my own lived experiences as a lifestyle vlogger on YouTube. Without challenging my conception of scholarship in the way our original Xchanges article did, I am not sure my research would have come to fruition. And more, I am not sure I would be in a position to teach students approaches to writing and rhetoric that remind them that their lived experiences are valuable ways of knowingâeven and especially within the academy.
Meganâs Reflections
As I review our original Xchanges piece, I find myself oscillating between two different frames of mind. On the one hand, I find myself remembering what it was like to be a graduate student in the first year of a combined MA/PhD program and all of the anxieties, questions, and unknowns that transition entailed. I remember acute feelings of imposter syndrome. Everyone was surely smarter than me? Everyone surely had read more than me? Everyone surely was there on purpose? But I was surely there by mistake. Tricky experiences from visiting campus as a prospective graduate student were still fresh in my mind as they involved me feeling like an outsider compared to the men who were prospective students in my program. These experiences lingered and erroneously served as âevidenceâ of my imposter syndrome. As I sought to intellectualize these worries, one of the main ways I could do so was to view them through the lens of gender. Doing so, in turn, led me to feel connected to feminist scholarship in rhetoric and composition. At the same time, the relationships I was building with Sarah and Laura also helped me make sense of these complicated experiences and feelings. It was feeling like an outsider and an imposter but also the relationships I formed that inspired my section of our original Xchanges piece. In writing the ârelation-relatingâ section, I hoped to remind others they are not alone and that they belong not only in graduate school but in the field as well.
On the other hand, as I reflect on our original piece, I find myself viewing these experiences and thoughts through the lens of what I have learned on the other side of graduate school. While it is meaningful to look back at our original piece and point to ways my thinking (both personally and professionally) has evolved for, what I believe, is the better, I also cannot help but notice those glaring moments where I do not think I had everything quite right. In particular, one theme of the original piece that stands out to me as being not quite right is our focus on individualism rather than solidarity and community. As our annotations reference, much of the framing we used to write about our experiences as graduate students was focused on the individual. This fact is reflected in everything from the title, âDoing it Herself,â to our consideration of how individuals can go about cultivating an ethe for themselves that is grounded in feminist philosophies and practices.
Upon reflection, I find this emphasis to be especially âstickyâ for two reasons (Ahmed, 2004). First, because the central purpose of my section of âDoing it Herselfâ was to encourage readers to foster connections, relationships, and community. And second, while in some ways the aim of this section might have been successful in reminding readers of the importance of building supportive, meaningful relationships with others, I also wonder about the ways it missed the mark. By focusing on a form of feminism in which one does it herself, I find myself wondering about who we were unintentionally leaving out, as Sarah describes above, and the implicit effects this approach can have on feminist efforts.
Additionally, these moments of foregrounding individuality rather than solidarity and community are especially noticeable to me because these ideas are central to my research today. Since working on our original piece, I found myself drawn to the field of community writingâscholarship in rhetoric and composition that 1) focuses on theories and practices for how to meaningfully write collaboratively with communities beyond the academy and 2) what this work can help us learn about the nature, study, and practice of writing. Reading the work of Paula Mathieu, Tom Deans, Linda Flower, and Ellen Cushman deeply inspired me as a first-year graduate student. Furthermore, learning about the field of community writing felt like finding an academic and scholarly community of which I could belong; I found myself relating with other scholars in the field and feeling inspired about the kind of work I wanted to do.
While our original Xchanges piece did not take up the field of community writing, I now realize the collaborative approach to the actual writing of âDoing it Herselfâ served as an early instance of what it means to put values of feminism and collaborative knowledge-making into practice, values that are also taken up and complicated in community writing. Because of the importance of collaboration and relationships in community writing, working with others to co-create knowledge has remained an important part of my scholarship. The CCCC Position Statement on Community-Engaged Scholarship in rhetoric and composition (2023) highlights the importance of collaboration and knowledge production in community writing, explaining that âknowledge is not held solely in university settings, but flows between communities.â Our original piece, then, served as an early model for what it means to do this work with others, and it helped me see collaborative writing and research as not only an asset but more so as a necessity for feminist work in rhetoric and composition. While it is important for individuals to cultivate a feminist ecological ethe through relating, it is also important to focus on how feminist visions of the future rely on a collaborative rather than individualistic approach to positive social change.
As I developed my own research trajectory and explored how I would like to contribute answers to some of the key questions of community writing, a feminist approach has remained central to my thinking. My work in community writing focuses on gender-based violence prevention and the ways that various community organizations go about supporting survivors. Because of the community-based context of my work, I found it to be ethically imperative to consider feminist approaches to community writing work. How could I think and write about community writing in the context of issues of gender-based violence without relying on feminist theory?
Looking back on our original piece, then, considering the importance of relationships, belonging, coalitions, and community through a feminist lens was not an anomaly but rather an approach to research in rhetoric and composition that still guides my thinking and scholarship. I think my story of relation-relating in âDoing it Herselfâ is indicative of a key question that has stuck with me. That is, what is the role of collaboration and relationship building in community writing and how can feminist theories and approaches help us reimagine this work? While I am still working through possible answers to this question, I hope that graduate student readers and early career scholars will remember that though our approaches, frameworks, and theories might change, the work we put into our early thinking and writing are necessary to the development of our longer intellectual trajectories.
