Guest Editorial: Looking Back, Writing Forward: Introduction to the 25th Anniversary Special Issue of Xchanges
by Jason Tham & Sweta Baniya | Xchanges 21.1, Fall 2026
When Julie Newmark and her editorial team founded Xchanges in 2000, they built the journal around the premise that undergraduate and graduate students are scholars capable of making knowledge worth reading. A quarter century later, that premise has hardened into a conviction, and the occasion of this anniversary invites us to look back at how far the idea has traveled—and to write forward toward what it might yet become. This special issue, “Looking Back, Writing Forward,” gathers eleven articles that do exactly that work of retrospection and reinvention. We asked the past and the new graduate student contributors to return to the journal’s archive, or to the author’s own earlier self, in order to ask what our fields have learned and what they still need to unlearn.
The Significance of Student Scholarship in Our Fields
The impulse to take student scholarship seriously has a longer history than Xchanges itself, though the journal has been one of its most durable homes. In the sciences, undergraduate research has long been a recognized rite of passage: students work in research labs, present posters, and are co-authors with their supervisors, but the humanities were slower to accept that students might produce rather than merely consume disciplinary knowledge. The Boyer Commission’s call to make inquiry-based learning the standard at research universities helped shift that assumption, and writing studies proved unusually receptive to it (Kinkead). Within a few years the field had built institutions to match the ambition: Young Scholars in Writing, the first international undergraduate research journal in rhetoric and writing studies, was founded by Laurie Grobman and Candace Spigelman in 2003, by which point Xchanges had already been publishing student work for three years. Grobman and Kinkead’s Undergraduate Research in English Studies later gave the movement a scholarly rationale, arguing that student inquiry belonged at the center of English studies rather than at its margins. What educational researchers such as Kuh would come to call a “high-impact practice” was, in writing studies, also a disciplinary argument: that novices, given a real audience and a real question, generate knowledge the field needs.
That argument carried a pedagogical corollary. Downs and Wardle’s influential case for reimagining first-year composition as an introduction to writing studies rested on the claim that students should engage the discipline’s questions directly, as knowledge-makers rather than as recipients of a generic academic discourse. To publish students, in other words, is not charity; it is a position about where knowledge in our fields comes from. Graduate education has followed a parallel arc. Stephen North’s portrait of composition as an “emerging field” was, in part, a story about how newcomers are inducted into a community’s ways of making knowledge, and the field’s rich literature on mentorship—Eble and Gaillet’s Stories of Mentoring among it—has long treated professionalization not as a gatekeeping ritual but as a relationship. Xchanges sits precisely at that intersection, where the publication of emerging scholars and their formation as future colleagues become the same act.
Technical and professional communication and writing across the curriculum have their own reasons to invest in student authorship. These are applied, situated disciplines whose knowledge is forged in classrooms, workplaces, writing centers, and community projects, the sites students inhabit most closely. Open-access, digital publication has made that contribution even more visible and circulable. A journal that lives online and charges nothing to read lowers the threshold for both writing and being read, which matters especially for the international, multilingual, and first-generation scholars who appear throughout this issue and for whom the ordinary gates of academic publishing can be steep. In this sense, the medium has always been part of the message: Xchanges has modeled a scholarly commons in which access, mentorship, and knowledge-making reinforce one another.
We write, too, as former student authors of this very journal. Jason Tham’s first peer-reviewed article, “Rhetorical Web Design: Thinking Critically about Ready-Made Web Templates and the Problem of Ease,” appeared in Xchanges while he was a doctoral student in the Rhetoric and Scientific and Technical Communication program at the University of Minnesota—an early venture into the digital and visual rhetorics that would become his research program. Sweta Baniya’s contribution to the journal’s Symposium on the Status of Graduate Study in Rhetoric and Composition, “The Necessity of Genre Disruption in Organizing an Advocacy Space for and by Graduate Students,” co-authored with Ashanka Kumari and Kyle Larson, grew out of her graduate-student labor building the nextGEN listserv as an international scholar finding her footing in the field. That same symposium issue is one to which four of this issue’s reflection authors return in these pages. For each of us, publishing in Xchanges was not a credential collected after the fact but part of how we became scholars—a first, formative experience of audience, peer review, and revision that professionalized us in the doing. We edit this anniversary issue, then, not only as its stewards but as its beneficiaries, and in the conviction that the work of publishing emerging scholars is inseparable from the work of forming them.
The Unique Position of Xchanges
This dual role is what makes the journal’s position distinctive. Xchanges is, first, a genuine venue: an open-access, peer-reviewed publication that devotes its fall issues to undergraduate research and its spring issues to graduate-student work, giving emerging authors a real place in the scholarly record rather than a simulated one. But it is also, and at the same time, a site of apprenticeship. For many contributors, an Xchanges article is a first experience of peer review—of revising for an audience of strangers, of watching one’s thinking take a shape the discipline can recognize. The journal professionalizes by publishing; it grooms future scholars not by holding them at the threshold but by walking them across it. As Jainab Banu argues in this issue, Xchanges thereby functions as a kind of pedagogical archive—a body of experience-based scholarship through which emerging teachers and researchers learn their craft from those only a step ahead of them. That the archive is now old enough to be revisited by a new generation is itself a measure of the journal’s success.
The journal’s rhythm—undergraduate research in the fall, graduate-student research in the spring—turns this apprenticeship into a deliberate structure. It stages a visible progression from the first upper-level thesis to the first peer-reviewed monograph-in-miniature, and it insists that each stage is scholarship in its own right, not a warm-up for the real thing. For us as guest editors, the effect is humbling. We came to these manuscripts expecting promise and instead found arguments: contributions to live debates about labor, language, technology, and pedagogy that any of the field’s established journals would be glad to host. Editing an anniversary issue meant learning, again, to read student work not as evidence of potential but as knowledge already in motion.
Reflection and Revisitation: The Articles
The eleven articles collected here take up the anniversary call’s two invitations—reflection by former authors and revisitation of the archive by new contributors—and, in practice, blur the line between them. Several pieces return to earlier Xchanges articles to ask what has changed. Shuvro Das revisits Jennifer Bracken Scott’s 2011 enthusiasm for teaching technical communication with wikis, reading the intervening rise of Google Docs, Notion, and other proprietary platforms through a decolonial lens that Web 2.0 optimism could not have anticipated. Athena Gordon and Catherine Hubka return to the ethics of visual rhetoric and photo manipulation, now recast for an age of deepfakes, generative AI, and “slopaganda.” Loren James Smith revisits Karen Ross’s meditation on Plato and pedagogy to examine the binary rhetoric—“cooked or cooking,” win or lose—that a neoliberal and gamified culture presses onto students. And in a coincidence that captures the issue’s spirit of intergenerational dialogue, two authors independently return to Angelyn Sommers’s article on narrative in the technical communication classroom: Elizabeth Caravella and Liz Martynova through a collaboratively written account of storytelling in a professional writing course, and Temitope Ojedele-Adejumo through a transnational framework of “embodied standpoint literacy” grounded in the experiences of Anglophone African graduate students.
Other contributors revisit the field’s foundational ideas rather than specific archival articles. Ekomabasi Obot Udoete turns Mary Louise Pratt’s “contact zone” back on the instructor, arguing through critical autoethnography that multilingual international graduate instructors are not merely facilitators of linguistic negotiation but subjects constituted within it, their authority made contingent by accent and perception. Ambir Khadka extends critical race theory’s tradition of counter-storytelling into networked digital ecologies, reading Nepal’s September 2025 Gen Z movement as a distributed rhetorical assemblage of multimodal expression and community listening. Braydon Dungan adapts peer writing-coach frameworks to the first-year composition classroom, narrating his own liminal passage from writing-center tutor to graduate instructor. And Jainab Banu reads the Xchanges archive itself as a source of informal mentoring knowledge for graduate teaching assistants—especially the international and multilingual instructors for whom the journal’s accumulated wisdom becomes a lifeline.
The reflection strand is anchored by authors returning to their own earlier pages. Bruce Kovanen and Andrew Bowman revisit their contribution to the journal’s Symposium on the Status of Graduate Study in Rhetoric and Composition, tracing their entangled trajectories as labor organizers and academics through a period in which the precarity they once described has only deepened. Sarah Fischer and Megan McCool return to their 2019 essay on cultivating a feminist ecological ethos in graduate school, now writing from tenure-track positions and materially enacting, rather than merely describing, the feminist practices of reflection and reimagination. Read together, these reflections do what the call hoped they would: they show research not as a static artifact but as a situated, unfolding practice that matures and migrates as its authors do.
What emerges across the issue is a portrait of writing studies, rhetoric, and technical communication thinking aloud about their own futures—about labor and precarity, about language difference and the translingual turn (Horner et al.), about artificial intelligence and platform capitalism, about narrative, feminism, and the ethics of representation. That such range should arise from student and early-career scholars is not incidental. It is the argument the journal has been making for 25 years.
With Gratitude to Our Reviewers
An issue built on peer review is only as strong as the reviewers who give their time to it, and we were fortunate in ours. Every manuscript here was strengthened by careful, generous, and often anonymous labor—the kind of mentoring-through-commentary that embodies exactly the ethic Xchanges was founded to sustain. With deep gratitude, we thank the colleagues who reviewed submissions to this special issue:
- Nasih Alam, North Dakota State University
- Erin Bahl, Kennesaw State University
- Jianfen Chen, Towson University
- Thais Rodrigues Cons, University of Arizona
- Annica Cox, University of New Mexico-Valencia Campus
- Jeremy Cushman, West Virginia University
- Taylor Dickinson, University of Wisconsin-Madison
- Alex Forbes, University of Colorado at Boulder
- Priyanka Ganguly, Texas Tech University
- Leigh Gruwell, Auburn University
- Menuka Gurung, University of Texas at El Paso
- Maggie Hart, University of Oklahoma
- Rachael Jordan, University of South Carolina
- Ashanka Kumari, East Texas A&M University
- Shiva Mainaly, University of Memphis
- Richard Mangum, Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University
- Annie Mendenhall, Georgia Southern University
- Sophia Minnillo, University of California Davis
- Zakery Munoz, Lehigh University
- Sahajiya Nath, Virginia Tech
- Mason Pellegrini, University of North Texas
- Amanda Presswood, Southern New Hampshire University
- Drew Virtue, Western Carolina University
- Carolyn Wisniewski, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
- Marisa Yerace, Weber State University
We are grateful, too, to the Xchanges editorial team and its founding vision, and above all to the contributors, who trusted us with their reflections and revisitations. Twenty-five years on, the journal’s founding wager—that emerging scholars have something the field needs to hear—looks less like a wager and more like a description of how our disciplines actually renew themselves. We are honored to look back with this issue, and to write forward with it.
— Jason Tham & Sweta Baniya
Issue Contents
- “From Wiki Pedagogy to Platformed Collaboration: Revisiting Collaborative Digital Writing in Technical Communication Through a Decolonial Lens” by Shuvro Das
- “BP & Sombrero Meme Deepfakes: Revisiting the Ethics of Synthetic Media in the Age of AI” by Cat Hubka and Athena C. Gordon
- “R U Cooked or R U Cooking?: Revisiting Platonic Binaries in a Neoliberal Age” by Loren James Smith
- “Hear, Tell, Live: Revisiting Storytelling in Technical & Professional Communication” by Elizabeth Caravella and Elizabeth Martynova
- “Re-Storying the Archive: Embodied Standpoint Literacy (EmSL) and the Transnational Reimagining of Narrative Pedagogy” by Temitope Ojedele-Adejumo
- “Teaching in the Contact Zone: The Lived Experience of an International Graduate Instructor” by Ekomabasi Obot Udoete
- “From Composition Classroom to Cloud: Digital Counter-Storytelling as Assemblage and Community Listening” by Ambir Khadka
- “From Coach to Classroom: Adapting Peer Writing Frameworks for Student-Centered FYC Instruction” by Braydon Dungan
- “Xchanging Ideas through Xchanges: Revisiting Selected Articles to Understand Graduate Teaching Assistants’ Pedagogical Praxis” by Jainab Tabassum Banu
- “Tracing Trajectories” by Andrew Bowman and Bruce Kovanen
- “Reflecting on & Reimagining Feminism in Rhetoric and Composition: From Graduate School to the Professoriate” by Sarah Fischer and Megan McCool
